Heh, and meanwhile, my own concern is that you may be over-correcting in your desire to be objective, and tending to give more validity to the typings you don't "want" the characters to be. I've had this problem myself, in the past. There are two kinds of bias: What you
hope the answer will be, and what you
fear the answer will be.
Of course, that's exactly the sort of thing I would say if I was being too hopeful in my own typings, so really, the only way to resolve this is the usual way: rational analysis of each others' supporting evidence.