@
shotgunfingers
"LSI-C - Melancholic - 6w5-8-4 So/Sx - FLEV - Holland Code: Realistic - ISTP"
Contradictions in your theory understanding add chances for your movement from nonsense LSI as your type.
You have 2 significant contradictions to Gulenko understanding of types, meanwhile baselessly trust to Gulenko's opinion about your type.
1. "P" as a behavior trait fits to what is called irrationality trait in Socionics. It's seen in dichotomy descriptions and in dichotomy tests of Socionics. LSI in Socionics is the type which always has the rationality of the behavior (to think before acting and be able to explain any done actions), according to its base rational function. It's nonsens to claim LSI and P type in the same time.
To have P is correct for you, but not LSI. Gulenko thinks you as having "rational" behavior, what fits to J only. While you think yourself as having P behavior - what is irrationality in Socionics. Your impulsivity and nonstability of a behavior - relates to irrationality and to P in MBTI test terms and Jung terms too (he used them as synonyms).
2. If you trust to Gulenko, then should think to have phlegmatic temper only. Gulenko types by temperaments much and strictly links J-I types with phlegmatic temper. If you think your temper as other - it's significant contradiction to what Gulenko thinks about you and your type. "melancholics" are P-I by Gulenko, - you should to have P with melancholic temper by Gulenko.
Taking how much you talk without good sense on the forum, besides tries to write something useful - it's more about extraverts.
And your emotionality style is close to Fe preference (if you have T type), what is against Te as ISTP.