didn't get a chance to look through the entire thread after page 1, but i did want to say that for me it's kind of a tough question to answer because i get attracted to someone not necessarily by how they "look", though that does participate to some extent. It's a total package, case-by-case basis sort of thing for me.

I can say what i find NOT attractive though, in all cases, like deal-breaker sort of things:

extreme skinniness
morbid obesity
pot belly
greasy hair
bad acne
stained teeth/poor oral hygiene
smoker breath
stinky
womanly fingers/fingernails
unkempt or dirty fingernails
shorter than 5'6" no matter how cute is unfortunately a deal breaker for me (sorry cute short guys...)

the rest all sorta depends.