Is there a correlation between the Big Five and Socionic type?

[anndelise]

People tend to score differently on the Big 5 according to particular roles or areas of their life. Such that a person will score differently as a Mother, than she would as a McD's worker, than she would as a Sister, than she would when persuing her hobby as a Skier.

[FDG]

Generally I'd say there is, but it's probably stronger for some types. There is a correlation between Big 5 and MBTI, and there is a correlation between MBTI and Socionics type, however:

- some russian articles show that the degree of perceived convergence between socionics and MBTI type is very strong for certain types and very weak for others.
- iterative application of a correlation function might lead to near-zero results and / or completely different ones

[noid]

there is relationship beetween all ptheory, even with Million Clinical Multiaxial Inventory.
Some ptheory go deeper (socionic (for model/dichotomie/interaction/IM processing), enneagram (for problem emotion)) while other stay ridiculously on the surface (type ABCD)

[Aquagraph]

- correlates somewhat with neuroticism.

I agree with the others, but why this?

[anndelise]

I've read somewhere that extroversion correlates with intelligence, so having an extroverted function as dominant will propably correlate with it cos, you know, Extroverts tend to be extrovert.

Not sure which version of extroversion you mean, but

Extroverts have reduced activity, in response to stimuli, in the neural circuit that keeps the brain aroused. As a result, they need more environmental stimuli to keep them feeling energized.

imo, and socionically related, Xe types spend more time/energy paying attention to TPE rather than relating/comparing/refining/'projecting an extension of' TPE. While an Xi is spending less time gathering Xe info, and more time doing what Xi elements do. Xi elements require more work, thus providing more brain stimulus from the inside, than an Xe element would.

[Aquagraph]

I agree with the others, but why this?

I didn't post this! That looked like an answer to my post which just vanished (and just reposted)! Am I having a discussion with myself?

[anndelise]

I didn't post this! That looked like an answer to my post which just vanished (and just reposted)! Am I having a discussion with myself?

Must be, and me too...cuz apparently i responded to a post of yours that doesn't exist.

[Aquagraph]

"Last edited by FDG"?

Whatever it is, it seems like someone tried to ask me why does correlate with being neurotic.
The wish to be precise and spesific is a one big way that seems to manifest itself.

People with strong seem to have tendency to underestimate intelligence of others and get frustrated by it.