I think I may be the same type as this guy

[Suz]

but... the point of the Dr. Answers video is to find some random trollish person on Youtube who's obviously not exactly "with it" at least as far as I can tell and trounce him to death with arguments that he probably doesn't have a chance of countering (as he's not really "with it")? the end is like a smiling invitation into the lion's den.

also, just because he's a "Christian" doesn't mean he has to believe in following the Ten Commandments to a T (unless he said that somewhere).

although I still can't apply this to types... I think that PR has a large focus on defeating people in arguments that perhaps outweighs other things... like having a good logically sound argument and winning with it is possibly more important than the substance of that argument? it's about PWNing and OWNing people.idk

Excellent points, especially the root of the issue in bold. That's what makes him Se valuing (if not Se-ego)... imo anyway.

[marooned]

Excellent points, especially the root of the issue in bold. That's what makes him Se valuing (if not Se-ego)... imo anyway.

yeah, i don't think i agree, either about them being excellent points or about them meaning Se valuing.

[Saoshyant]

I want to say INTj, but I am not real confident in that. Definitely a polarizing character.

[Suz]

yeah, i don't think i agree, either about them being excellent points or about them meaning Se valuing.

Um...ok then why did you make them, and what do you think those points mean?

[Crispy]

After watching all the videos in this thread my best guess is INTj, followed by ISTj. I'll watch more of him later, as he seems quite hilarious.

[Galen]

I have no idea how this guy could be "too intense" to be ISTp, unless everybody's conception of an ISTp is an apathetic homebody. Nanashi is much more intense than this guy, and she's most definitely Te-INTp.

[Suz]

I have no idea how this guy could be "too intense" to be ISTp, unless everybody's conception of an ISTp is an apathetic homebody. Nanashi is much more intense than this guy, and she's most definitely Te-INTp.

But Nanashi is Ni/Se valuing. I dont buy the Ip = laid back, apathetic.

However, there is this sharpness to the guy's tongue that doesn't quite mesh well with my impression of SLIs. Also the desire to PWN like Loki mentioned. The guy actually strikes me as an extravert for the simple reason that he decided to make these videos to voice his views, and he saw the need to respond to that other guy's video, in great detail at that. That's external initiative-taking imo.

My impression of an ISTp is not an "apathetic homebody" btw, not even close. But it's definitely not someone who would specifically make it a point to create a video to rant about things. I once saw a "video" of DeAnte--it was a 10 second clip where he was like "Name's DeAnte. Hi. <end>" lol. They dont like the spotlight.

[marooned]

that was the one thing i felt rather confident about... he really doesn't seem like an irrational to me in the least.

[Galen]

But Nanashi is Ni/Se valuing. I dont buy the Ip = laid back, apathetic.

I don't see why that would make any real difference when comparing her to him. Nanashi is equally as animated as this guy from what I can tell.

However, there is this sharpness to the guy's tongue that doesn't quite mesh well with my impression of SLIs. Also the desire to PWN like Loki mentioned. The guy actually strikes me as an extravert for the simple reason that he decided to make these videos to voice his views, and he saw the need to respond to that other guy's video, in great detail at that. That's external initiative-taking imo.

Well then you should probably broaden your view of ISTps. I mean look at people like Thunderf00t: he's definitely an introvert (Ne-INTj) and he puts out videos like PR all the time. Anybody with fervent beliefs about anything or reactions to things is going to act on them, regardless of the type in question.

And I'm not convinced that he makes those videos just for the sake of "pwning" other people. I've yet to see real evidence for that.

My impression of an ISTp is not an "apathetic homebody" btw, not even close. But it's definitely not someone who would specifically make it a point to create a video to rant about things. I once saw a "video" of DeAnte--it was a 10 second clip where he was like "Name's DeAnte. Hi. <end>" lol. They dont like the spotlight.

If ISTps didn't like the spotlight then there would be no ISTp actors, singers, or anything like that. Those sorts of sweeping comments have approximately 0 merit as far as I'm concerned. Also, see the above comment about fervent beliefs.

[Suz]

I don't see why that would make any real difference when comparing her to him. Nanashi is equally as animated as this guy from what I can tell.


Well then you should probably broaden your view of ISTps. I mean look at people like Thunderf00t: he's definitely an introvert (Ne-INTj) and he puts out videos like PR all the time. Anybody with fervent beliefs about anything or reactions to things is going to act on them, regardless of the type in question.

And I'm not convinced that he makes those videos just for the sake of "pwning" other people. I've yet to see real evidence for that.


If ISTps didn't like the spotlight then there would be no ISTp actors, singers, or anything like that. Those sorts of sweeping comments have approximately 0 merit as far as I'm concerned. Also, see the above comment about fervent beliefs.

Mkay i didn't mean "the spotlight" in the literal sense. Even the ISTp actors/singers sort of keep a low profile and dont particularly call attention to themselves (yes i have studied many of them...surprise surprise ). Nor do they seem to have the inclination to care to make public efforts to reach out in criticism like this guy has. It doesn't matter whether his intentions are to "PWN" or not. He's reaching out, taking initiative to criticize and going to great lengths to arrange this. That's extraversion to me. Also he displays too much Fe in the inflections of his voice and facial features to be an Fe-POLR. An INTj (Fe-seeking) would be more likely to do something like this than an ISTp would, though I still question your typing of him if this is the case.

Maybe you ought to adjust the way you're interpreting what I say. Also, you dont seem to have a good understanding of SLIs.

A little condescension adjustment wouldn't hurt either. People who disagree with you may actually have a point and with your closed mind your growth will stop (as i think it did. You are getting a little too cocky and have been for a while now).

[Galen]

Mkay i didn't mean "the spotlight" in the literal sense. Even the ISTp actors/singers sort of keep a low profile and dont particularly call attention to themselves (yes i have studied many of them...surprise surprise ). Nor do they seem to have the inclination to care to make public efforts to reach out in criticism like this guy has. It doesn't matter whether his intentions are to "PWN" or not. He's reaching out, taking initiative to criticize and going to great lengths to arrange this. That's extraversion to me.

Well it's not extroversion. I can't really put it any more succinctly or detailed than that.

Also he displays too much Fe in the inflections of his voice and facial features to be an Fe-POLR. An INTj (Fe-seeking) would be more likely to do something like this than an ISTp would, though I still question your typing of him if this is the case.

His vocal inflections seem normal enough for an Fe-PoLR. Again, look to Nanashi for reference. If you want to see how an "Fe-seeking" person would argue in the same situation as PR, look to Thunderf00t. The differences between him and this guy should be pretty apparent.

Maybe you ought to adjust the way you're interpreting what I say. Also, you dont seem to have a good understanding of SLIs.

no u

A little condescension adjustment wouldn't hurt either. People who disagree with you may actually have a point and with your closed mind your growth will stop (as i think it did. You are getting a little too cocky and have been for a while now).

I'm sorry, but as of yet I'm just not seeing any reasonable arguments against ISTp. I'm not sure where I start to come off as cocky though, so if you could point that out to me?

[Park]

Who the hell is Nanashi?

[Suz]

Well it's not extroversion. I can't really put it any more succinctly or detailed than that.

You dont need to be succint. Explain away. I want to know if i'm wrong.

His vocal inflections seem normal enough for an Fe-PoLR. Again, look to Nanashi for reference. If you want to see how an "Fe-seeking" person would argue in the same situation as PR, look to Thunderf00t. The differences between him and this guy should be pretty apparent.

Can u link me?

no u

no U!!

I'm not sure where I start to come off as cocky though, so if you could point that out to me?

aww, i'm sorry Galen. U know I u. Forget I said it.

[Park]

This one is interesting

A Te-INTp user on here. She goes on the socionix tinychat a lot.

I've never seen or heard of her.

And I'm not convinced that he makes those videos just for the sake of "pwning" other people. I've yet to see real evidence for that.

Because it's bullshit.

[Galen]

Wow, that was really intense.

I've never seen or heard of her.

Well she exists. Trust me.

[JuJu]

the guy in the videos is Ne and Ti valuing -- from what I've seen, I'd wager he's alpha NT.


There is a lot of Ne in his videos. For example:

In that last one: "there are four things that she left out, for example, if the doctor..." His mind goes wild with speculation, thinking of all possibilities -- each of which gets "bigger."

In a Ti regimented style, he numbers his points.

He seems to be SI seeking. E.g. "I really need some sleep," and "sorry about the lighting."


I don't believe that he's beta or delta, i.e. ISTj or ISTp.

[Suz]

the guy in the videos is Ne and Ti valuing -- from what I've seen, I'd wager he's alpha NT.


There is a lot of Ne in his videos. For example:

In that last one: "there are four things that she left out, for example, if the doctor..." His mind goes wild with speculation, thinking of all possibilities -- each of which gets "bigger."

In a Ti regimented style, he numbers his points.

He seems to be SI seeking. E.g. "I really need some sleep," and "sorry about the lighting."


I don't believe that he's beta or delta, i.e. ISTj or ISTp.

Yeah actually, I could see ILE for him. Totally. And that would explain Parkster's fascination with him too . (though i also agree with everything the guy said in that Oklahoma video).

[Trevor]

Ne-EP ENTp would be my wild guess. Don't ask questions. Don't quote me on this. Just vibes and VI. It's a guess.

[glam]

hahaha unfortunately i can relate to his Arby's girl story...


anyway i think this guy could be LII. they get intense like that when talking about something that's exciting/agitating them.

[Galen]

anyway i think this guy could be LII. they get intense like that when talking about something that's exciting/agitating them.

I've seen ISTps get angry in the same way as this guy, i.e. Keith Olbermann.

[Park]

Wow, that was really intense.

While I may not jump out of bed to film myself, that's exactly how I feel and react to such things. I WILL however jump out of bed if it's about something or someone dear/important to me.

hahaha unfortunately i can relate to his Arby's girl story...

You have chased a girl?

anyway i think this guy could be LII. they get intense like that when talking about something that's exciting/agitating them.

I do, too.

[Words]

I have no idea how this guy could be "too intense" to be ISTp, unless everybody's conception of an ISTp is an apathetic homebody. Nanashi is much more intense than this guy, and she's most definitely Te-INTp.

I don't have the inclination to watch all the videos or re-watch what i've seen. I can't see, based on what i've seen of his looks, his body language and his words, how he can have a subjective sensation impression of the environment, he doesn't exhibit behaviour or qualities I see in those who either have it as a leading function or value it. The 'edgyness' I mentioned describes the combination of his looks, his mannerisms and words in such a way which doesn't reflect a leading Si mode of processing his environment.