Can one be typed correctly by Reinin dichotomies alone?

[xerx]

The null / non-null dichotomy works consistently IME.

[Brilliand]

Karnaugh map listens to previous posters and says...

Use quadra, temperament and club separately; don't mix them!

Quadra triple:
-Merry/Serious
-Judicious/Decisive
-Aristocrat/Democrat

Temperament triple:
-Rational/Irrational
-Extratim/Introtim
-Static/Dynamic

Club triple:
-Sensing/Intuitive
-Thinking/Feeling
-Aristocrat/Democrat

EDIT: Specifically, the Karnaugh map came up with the rule that a dichotomy is useful if is ignores temperament OR ignores club OR is either Merry/Serious or Judicious/Decisive. I used the four Jungian dichotomies as the four variables for the map.

[krieger]

There is a secret fourth triple:

Negative/Postive
Process/Result
Static/Dynamic

AKA thought style.

[The Exception]

There is a secret fourth triple:

Negative/Postive
Process/Result
Static/Dynamic

AKA thought style.

Do you have descriptions for these different thought styles?

[Krig the Viking]

Do you have descriptions for these different thought styles?

http://www.the16types.info/vbulletin...g-gulenko.html

[FDG]

Actually, typing by Reinin dichotomies can often be extremely effective, given that they're highly exclusive (i.e. you only need to identify a small amount of them (5) in order to reduce your possible typings to one).

Use quadra, temperament and club separately; don't mix them!

Quadra triple:
-Merry/Serious
-Judicious/Decisive
-Aristocrat/Democrat

Temperament triple:
-Rational/Irrational
-Extratim/Introtim
-Static/Dynamic

Club triple:
-Sensing/Intuitive
-Thinking/Feeling
-Aristocrat/Democrat

I'd say the best results for typing by Reinin dichotomies would be obtained with an algorithm such as this:
1) Pick 2 triples of your choice
2) Pick one of the triples you chooses at 1); pick two dichotomies among the 3, then identify precisely which reinin dichotomies fits you for each component pertaining to given triple
3) Pick the remaining triple and choose 2 reinin dichotomies.
4) Identify precisely which reinin dichotomy fits you for each of the 2 choices at point 3).

Only one type should remain. A useful "trick" is: don't try to "fit" every reinin dichotomy to whatever type you think you are: only a handful are necessary in order to exclude every other possibility.

[Simon Ssmall]

I get correct results when I go through each of those descriptions and then use:

(googletrasnlate the link)
Êàëüêóëÿòîð Ðåéíèíà

It allows to add values where you are not sure while going all out on dichotomies you are definately sure of.