How is MBTI J/P different from Socionics j/p

[Hugo]

Without giving descriptions for j/p MBTI and j/p Socionics please state the precise differences of both.

[Ave]

MBTI and socionics experts beleive that people have two different types of life rythms. The criteria they use to define these life rythms does not differ any more than the criteria they use to define extraversion and introversion. The difference comes in the theoritical explanation for why these types of life rythms occur. Socionists beleive that judging charcteristics stem from having a judging/rational function as the dominant function and perceiving characterists stem from having a perceiving function as the dominant function.
MBTI experts beleive that judging charcteristics stem from the fact that one of the two functions(either dominant or auxillary) is extraverted and judging at the same time. Since either the dominant function or the auxillary is judging(and the other is perceiving) MBTI experts atrribute judging characteristics to the extraversion of the judging function. Socionists atrribute it to the judging function, regardless of whether or not it is extraverted. So in MBTI judging is a sign that a judging function is not only judging, but extraverted as well.

For example ENTP in MBTI is a perceiving type, because its dominant function is and its auxillary function is . INTP(socionics INTP) is a judging type in MBTI: it has as dominant function and as auxillary function. Which is why the is called INTJ in MBTI. Socionics INTJ is a perceiving type in MBTI: dominant with auxillary . In MBTI, type is perceiving because the extraverted function( ) is perceiving.

confusing enough for you?