If the four different socionics groups were the four different houses at hogwarts

[Khola aka Bee]

Which one would be which and why? Discuss.

[Ezra]

This does not work. They are a combination of more than one quadra.

Here's what I reckon:

Ravenclaw: Alpha NTs, ILI
Slytherin: Beta STs (maybe with some EIEs)
Gryffindor: Gamma SFs, LIE
Hufflepuff: Deltas (possibly the only house which generally contains all Deltas, but I could see ESEs here)

I don't know where IEIs could go.

[Ezra]

Ti loading

Ti working... 28% complete

Ti working... 57% complete

Ti working... 89% complete

Ti command 100%

LIIs not compatible with Gryffindor. Access denied.

[aestrivex]

as ezra said, no direct correlation. ezra's correlations are too broad. this is something that can't be handled on a purely socionics basis.

[aka-kitsune]

This does not work. They are a combination of more than one quadra.

Here's what I reckon:

Ravenclaw: Alpha NTs, ILI
Slytherin: Beta STs (maybe with some EIEs)
Gryffindor: Gamma SFs, LIE
Hufflepuff: Deltas (possibly the only house which generally contains all Deltas, but I could see ESEs here)

I don't know where IEIs could go.

I'd reckon some IEIs would end up in Ravenclaw and some in Gryffindor. As much as the Harry Potter series leans Gryffindor-centric, Ravenclaw seems more appropriate a match for IEI as a combination of intuition, intellect and aesthetic.

[Suomea]

Ravenclaw: Alpha/Delta
Slytherin: Beta
Gryffindor: Alpha
Hufflepuff: Delta

[Slacker]

I think everyone puts their own quadra as Gryffindor because everyone identifies with the lead characters.

Anyway, IMO

Ravenclaw - Gamma
Slytherin - Beta
Hufflepuff - Alpha
Griffindor - Delta

But I think Hermione is ENTj so who knows.

[aestrivex]

i would like to be in ravenclaw.

[Iconoclast IX]

i would like to be in ravenclaw.

Same.

I do not know why anyone would want to be in Gryffindor. Most of them are complete losers.

[Suomea]

I think everyone puts their own quadra as Gryffindor because everyone identifies with the lead characters.

Anyway, IMO

Ravenclaw - Gamma
Slytherin - Beta
Hufflepuff - Alpha
Griffindor - Delta

But I think Hermione is ENTj so who knows.

I really don't know Harry Potter very well so don't put very much weight in my typings at all. From the movie I would strongly suggest Harry Potter is either Alpha or Delta though with his complete resistance to Se pressure. Delta seems like it could easily be a good bet.

[Logos]

I think everyone puts their own quadra as Gryffindor because everyone identifies with the lead characters.

Anyway, IMO

Ravenclaw - Gamma
Slytherin - Beta
Hufflepuff - Alpha
Griffindor - Delta

But I think Hermione is ENTj so who knows.

Not I. If the usual variety of Harry Potter fans will be in Griffindor and the emo kids in Slytherin, then you can find me in either Ravenclaw (more than likely) or Hufflepuff, and Hufflepuff sounds like self-esteem boosting school for fat kids.

[hellothere]

I think everyone puts their own quadra as Gryffindor because everyone identifies with the lead characters.

Anyway, IMO

Ravenclaw - Gamma
Slytherin - Beta
Hufflepuff - Alpha
Griffindor - Delta

But I think Hermione is ENTj so who knows.

For some reason I kind of see Hermione as INFj

[munenori2]

I'm not an HP reader, but when I read through the houses and got to the fourth one I had to laugh. Hufflepuff? Really? What is their mascot?



Honestly, I think a special circle in hell would be reserved for anyone having to endure being called a hufflepuff. Likely just the first circle though.

[iAnnAu]

I think SLI's are Ravenclaw.
Although I'll chime in with wanting to be in Gryffindor, too, of course!

[Ezra]

I think SLI's are Ravenclaw.

With an intellectual capacity of zero? I think not.

[Socionics Is A Cult]

Honestly, I think a special circle in hell would be reserved for anyone having to endure being called a hufflepuff. Likely just the first circle though.

I think there should be a special circle in hell for those who immediately think that Hufflepuff rhymes with Jigglypuff upon reading the word.

[munenori2]

I think there should be a special circle in hell for those who immediately think that Hufflepuff rhymes with Jigglypuff upon reading the word.

, true. I was just curious what animal they use to rep themselves (aka griffon/raven/snake/?????). Anyone know?

[Socionics Is A Cult]

Badger. I can't remember where I read it, but badgers are suppose to be a symbol of monks, and are obvious geared up to toiling the soil.

[Iconoclast IX]

, true. I was just curious what animal they use to rep themselves (aka griffon/raven/snake/?????). Anyone know?

A badger is used as the representative, if I am not mistaken.

[marooned]

LII - Ravenclaw > Hufflepuff or Gryffindor
ILE - Ravenclaw, Hufflepuff > Slytherin
SEI - Hufflepuff > Gryffindor
ESE - Hufflepuff
EIE - Gryffindor > Slytherin
IEI - Gryffindor or Hufflepuff > Slytherin
SLE - Gryffindor or Slytherin
LSI - Ravenclaw, Gryffindor > Slytherin
LIE - Ravenclaw or Slytherin > Gryffindor
ILI - Ravenclaw > Slytherin
SEE - Hufflepuff or Gryffindor
ESI - Gryffindor or Slytherin > Ravenclaw
EII - Hufflepuff or Gryffindor
IEE - Hufflepuff
SLI - Hufflepuff or Ravenclaw > Slytherin
LSE - Ravenclaw > Hufflepuff

Ni/Se valuing goes more strongly with Slytherin and Gryffindor
Ne/Si valuing goes more strongly with Hufflepuff
Ravenclaw... is actually ubiquitous

[Tigerfadder]

This will be a bump, I just saw a trailer for HP go.

I would put gryffindor as a merry house and slytherin as serious.

Here what I found:
Gryffindor values bravery, daring, nerve, and chivalry.
Hufflepuff, founded by Helga Hufflepuff, values hard work, dedication, patience, loyalty, and fair play.
Ravenclaw values intelligence, knowledge, and wit.
Slytherin house values ambition, cunning and resourcefulness.

Most of the saga centre around Gryffindor and there are a lot of friendships and drama going on there. People agree that harry is the ESI type and so the saga is also centered around a Fi type. Gryffindor is a merry quadra with character as weasley's which could easily go for alpha. The weasley twins later start a shop which focus on magic tricks and fun items. The Slytherin got to be a serious quadra and focus a lot on status in the books. The professor of slytherin is a guy with secrets, he is the bad guy in all the book but in the end it turned out he did it all in love. Hufflepuff I view as a merry quadra aswell and their professor is a semi-mad women teaching herbology. I do not know much about these but these seem to be the most curious people. Ravenclaw is a serious quadra with the heads in the books and is a bit sneaky. They aim for maximal academic achievement and knows everything. Hermione was supposed to be Ravenclaw.


Ravenclaw - Delta
Slytherin - Gamma
Hufflepuff - Alpha
Griffindor - Beta

[wasp]

http://sortinghatchats.tumblr.com/po...113/the-basics

"Your Primary House defines WHY you do things. Your Secondary defines HOW."

[Chae]

I experimented trying to assign the IEs to the houses and it worked out like this, I added enneagram and stackings because they contribute to the big picture:

	Quadra	e-type: primary> other likely ones	Instinct Stackings
G	Beta - Se daring bravery and fighting spirit, Fe merrymaking and motivation - chivalry even, Ti hierarchies, Ni long term goals	8 > 3,7	Sx/So, So/Sp
H	Alpha - Si providing and caring for the others, Fe affability and good spirits, Ti consistency, Ne quirkiness and novelty while seeing potential in others	2 > 6,9	So/Sx, Sp/So
S	Gamma - Te efforts and conservation, Fi close bonds/loyalty/origin family bias (?), Se competitiveness, Ni cunning calculation	3 > 1,8	Sp/Sx, Sx/Sp
R	Delta - Ne + Te vast knowledge that's either interesting and/or applicable for experimentation, Si comfort - smartness over battle, Fi subdued but strong affection	5 > 4, 6, 9	Sp/So, Sp/Sx

Feel free to critique and add.

[mclane]

Gryffindor -- Gamma/Delta (+Se, +Fi)
Slytherin -- Beta (+Ti, -Ni)
Ravenclaw -- Alpha/Gamma (-Ti, -Te,+Ne, +Ni)
Hufflepuff -- Delta/Gamma/Alpha (-Si, -Fi, +Si)

[Soupman]

Gryffindor = F & Dominant subtypes
Slytherin = I & creative subtypes
RavenClaw = L & normalising subtypes
Hufflepuff = R & harmonising subtypes

[The Exception]

Gryffindor = F & Dominant subtypes
Slytherin = I & creative subtypes
RavenClaw = L & normalising subtypes
Hufflepuff = R & harmonising subtypes

Gryffindor- C or D
Slytherin- D mostly, maybe some C
Ravenclaw- C mostly, maybe some N
Hufflepuff- H mostly, maybe some N

[Soupman]

Gryffindor- C or D
Slytherin- D mostly, maybe some C
Ravenclaw- C mostly, maybe some N
Hufflepuff- H mostly, maybe some N

Normalisers are more level headed and intellectual than, Creatives who are all about bending the rules and seeking personal recognition. Dominants' primary motivation is winning, they care less about the games and unorthodox means.