Quote Originally Posted by Wyrd View Post
It's not wrong in principle though, which is what you seem to be claiming. If you define that Ij types are not externally orderly in MBTI, then anyone who is externally orderly is not an Ij type in MBTI. MBTI is just a bunch of principles to try to explain what you see. If it makes everyone ESxJ beyond the point where it's not even vaguely useful to type someone as that, that's just proof it's silly, but not that it's internally wrong. That's like asking "What did the bank robbers look like?" "Oh, they all had two legs." That's nearly completely useless, but not wrong.
I don't think MBTI makes everyone ESxJ...

Yes, it's wrong in principle because "trait X" is a Rationality one (I didn't explicitly say so because I thought the previous context indicated it). This idea that introverted functions are not observable in behaviour or other manifestations (speech etc) is crazy.


Thanks. This is the elaborated version of a Dalí sketch but no one is saying whether this one is done by him or not, and who else exactly did it if it's someone else.
Ah, cool.