A lot of people are of the opinion that an MBTI INTJ is a socionics INTp and vice versa. Let's find it out by analyzing the descriptions in detail...
Ideas are an Alpha-NT domain. INTj is strategic wheras INTp is tactical.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
1:0
Confusing passage because they interpret Ni completely differently than in socionics. Again, ideas are INTj but applying instead of understanding concepts is INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
1:1
INTj is harder to understand than INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
2:1
INTj is strategic, INTp is tactical.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
3:1
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
3.5:1.5
INTj is clearly more arrogant and harder to understand.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
4.5:1.5
Business and efficiency are INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
4.5:2.5
Hard to tell. Applies to both in a way.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
5:3
This point goes to the INTj who is Se-vulnerable, even though it might also apply to some INTps.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
6:3
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
6.5:3.5
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
7:4
Conclusion
7:4 is not a very clear result but in my opinion it is rather a description of the type we know as Analyst in socionics.
Let's look at the INTP:
Analyze problems, identify patterns, logical explanations. Clearly INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0:1
Generate theories, enthusiasm, ignoring rules, new ideas. Definitely INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0:2
Depends on subtype.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0.5:2.5
Definitely INTp. Constructivist, objectivist and Fe-vulnerable. INTj is emotivist, subjectivist and Fe is his dual-seeking function.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
1.5:2.5
Self-aggrandizement, social rebellion and creative potential are clearly INTj traits. The rest applies to both in a way so the point goes to the INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
1.5:3.5
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:4
Unconventional instead of traditional. INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:5
New thoughts are an Alpha domain. INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:6
Conclusion
The INTJ scored 7:4 and the INTP even 6:2 as INTj. So both are Analysts and not Critics, probably with different subtypes. Maybe the guys on personalitypage are going to write a description of the socionics INTp-Critic soon...