Okay, I just completed a study of each type's
subtype descriptions on Wikisocion, the ones by Viktor Gulenko as well as Valentine Meged & Anatoly Ovcharov. I was very surprised at what I found. While the subtype descriptions of Introverted types seemed to match up quite well between authors, subtype descriptions of Extraverted types did not match up well, and for the most part did so in a predictable pattern! In EJ types, Meged/Ovcharov seemed to describe the Creative and Normalizing subtypes, while Gulenko described the Harmonizing and Dominant subtypes. In EP types the pattern was reversed: Meged/Ovcharov seemed to describe the Harmonizing and Dominant types, while Gulenko described the Creative and Normalizing. The only possible exception was LSE, where I found it difficult to tell.
Here are my results:
LIE Intuitive Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Creative, Gulenko describes Harmonizing.
LIE Logical Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Normalizing, Gulenko describes Dominant.
EIE Intuitive Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Creative, Gulenko describes Harmonizing.
EIE Ethical Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Normalizing, Gulenko describes Dominant.
ESE Sensory Subtype: Difficult to tell, but does seem to follow previous pattern of Meged/Ovcharov Creative, Gulenko Harmonizing.
ESE Ethical Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Normalizing, Gulenko describes Dominant.
LSE Sensory Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Creative, Gulenko describes Harmonizing. May be some Harmonizing in Meged/Ovcharov description as well.
LSE Logical Subtype: Difficult to tell. Meged/Ovcharov may be describing Dominant and Gulenko Normalizing, but that doesn't fit the pattern.
IEE Intuitive Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Harmonizing, Gulenko describes Creative.
IEE Ethical Subtype: Meged Ovcharov describe Dominant, Gulenko describes Normalizing.
SEE Sensory Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Harmonizing(?), Gulenko describes Creative.
SEE Ethical Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Dominant, Gulenko describes Normalizing.
SLE Sensory Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Harmonizing(?), Gulenko describes Creative(?).
SLE Logical Subtype: Meged/Ovcharov describe Dominant (?), Gulenko describes Normalizing.
I honestly did not expect to find a pattern this clear. Entirely by accident on the part of the authors, we now have a short description of each of the DCNH subtypes for extravert types (except possibly LSE). This clears up some things, as I had previously regarded these subtype descriptions as confusing and self-contradictory. Knowing that Gulenko and Meged/Ovcharov were describing different subtypes half the time makes a lot more sense.