Thread: The irrational/rational dichotomy

1. The irrational/rational dichotomy

My take is irrational/rational relationships are destined to kinda suck. Even though I'm an irrational type I def recognize that rationals are necessary in a grip of ways. However, I still hesitate to date my activity (EIE) cause I believe they decide too quick. I'd probably date (not marry) a mirage before I did an activity.

I'm wondering if others have a similar experience on this one.

2. I agree with this.

I’ve seen a lot of j/p relationships and they always seem like the house looks mostly OK from the outside, but the foundation is broken.

As if, when you dive really deeply into the relationship, there are fundamental and unfixable differences.

3. Irrational and rational have unfortunate dictionary meanings; the so-called dichotomy should be labelled input (p) and output (j) oriented respectively. It's difficult for these two orientations to remain on the same path, have non-conflicting approaches or methods, and or have similar measures of achievement or success unless there's a governing authority. They can have very similar interests but usually for very differing reasons. Some pairs start out well together, which can be maintained while they remain independent of one another, but when they become dependent on one another, they see that they view life completely differently. Mirror pairs are the poster-children of this dichotomy.

a.k.a. I/O

4. Originally Posted by Rebelondeck
Irrational and rational have unfortunate dictionary meanings; the so-called dichotomy should be labelled input (p) and output (j) oriented respectively. It's difficult for these two orientations to remain on the same path, have non-conflicting approaches or methods, and or have similar measures of achievement or success unless there's a governing authority. They can have very similar interests but usually for very differing reasons. Some pairs start out well together, which can be maintained while they remain independent of one another, but when they become dependent on one another, they see that they view life completely differently. Mirror pairs are the poster-children of this dichotomy.

a.k.a. I/O
I know three or four ESI-ILI marriages and one LIE-SEE marriage, and they got together quick and now are showing contempt for each other. All of them.

I have a ton of ILI friends. I like them. I dated an ILI female for a while and I really liked the way her mind worked, but I really, really couldn’t imagine being married to her.

5. Activity > mirage imo. I would never date my mirror.

6. Originally Posted by Poptart
Activity > mirage imo. I would never date my mirror.
I've had far better casual relationships with mirage partners than with activity. I would expect that mirages find me overly distant while I find a lot of them aggressively opinionated. Now, most activity partners seem find me downright irritating while I find many of them overly defensive, with few opinions of their own and or easily insulted or hurt; however, relationships with them weren't nearly as bad as those with mirrors. Mirrors tend to think that their partners are doing it all wrong and should be stopped.

a.k.a. I/O

7. I'm not exactly singing the praises of mirage here. Just find that the j/p (or rational/irrational) dichotomy matters in close distances. After working with both an Fe dom (EIE) & a Ti dom at my job (I'm an SLE) for some time, their J preference becomes irritating. Meanwhile, the two mirages (Fe subtypes) at work flow better

I'd say people on the net overrate activity. Mirrors have the J preference but are also redundant. They simply repeat crap you're already aware of.

Again, nothing against J's. Society needs 'em for sure

8. How do you folk actually deal with the rational/irrational dichotomy? I'm guessing people gotta adapt. Personally, that dichotomy just irritates me. Rationals serve the world in a decent way but one has to be careful choosing intimate partnerships.

This is a decent thread topic, if you're interested
https://www.the16types.info/vbulleti...tivity-partner

9. My parents are matching subtype activity partners but they have a happy marriage (ILI-Ni, ESI-Se). They also each come from different cultures but deep down their values and lifestyle are very similar. I've actually started noticing when there are type related clashes that duality would solve (j/p for example), but for NTR reasons they stick well.

Personally J/P is the one thing i'm not very innately perceptive about in socionics, for whatever reason. i seem to pay much more attention to valuation than temperament.
in terms of general relationships (platonic or otherwise) i do know i prefer Pe individuals, but I've been rather close to Pi and Ji individuals in the past.

10. Hmm but in another thread didn't you say that IEIs can annoy you cuz we decide too slowly? So what amount of time exactly would be the sweet spot for somebody making a choice that would be appealing/sexy to you? lol

Anyways I think all relationships are destined to suck until they don't. I don't think it makes much difference one way or another.

11. Originally Posted by BandD

Anyways I think all relationships are destined to suck until they don't. I don't think it makes much difference one way or another.
Do you mean that they will suck until you find some sort of unspoken understanding of how to be around each other? Or do you mean that they suck until you meet the right people who you get on better with?

12. Do you mean that they will suck until you find some sort of unspoken understanding of how to be around each other? Or do you mean that they suck until you meet the right people who you get on better with?
Both, really. Finding the right people is important but doing the former takes effort and practice and more nuanced finesse.

13. Originally Posted by BandD
Hmm but in another thread didn't you say that IEIs can annoy you cuz we decide too slowly? So what amount of time exactly would be the sweet spot for somebody making a choice that would be appealing/sexy to you? lol

Anyways I think all relationships are destined to suck until they don't. I don't think it makes much difference one way or another.
IEI annoy me most when they persist in Ni delusion. If a particular path is really important to an IEI, its their responsibility to research & investigate instead of running through first like a chicken with its head cut off

There's no rule I just dig it when IEI honestly give a shit about their life choices. If you're 30 don't have the psychological maturity of a retarded grade school kid

There's a reason pets exist. They kinda make better friends than people sometimes.

14. They kinda make better friends than people sometimes.
Sometimes?!

15. Originally Posted by BandD

Sometimes?!
Legit LOL

Posting Permissions

• You may not post new threads
• You may not post replies
• You may not post attachments
• You may not edit your posts
•