Goethe's Faust Movie (Hollywood version) Casting
God: Morgan Freeman
Mephistopheles: Craig Ferguson
Faust: David Bowie (assuming he's alive)
Gretchen: Anne Hathaway
Who else would you personally cast? Every minor part must be filled! Make Hollywood Great Again: Stop the dumb superhero movies and recite the entire German national drama in English using the most pretentious members of modern English-speaking popular culture as actors!
Faust: Eine deutsche Volkssage, 1926
Director F. W. Murnau
Probably before your time, but a good movie. I don't really remember the actors.
God: Sean Connery / Jimmy Carter / Paul McCartney / Arnold Schwarzenegger
Mephistopheles: Bob Dylan / Tilda Swinton / J. K. Rowling / Björk
Faust: Henry Kissinger / Noam Chomsky / Keith Richards / Stephen King
Gretchen: Cher / Shakira / Ayumi Hamasaki / Paris Hilton