Has anybody seen this show? It just ended it's first season a week or two ago. Thoughts? Types?
My take:
Hannah - ENTp
Marnie - Exxj
Shoshana - ?
Jessa - Ixxx
Adam - ISTj maybe?
HBO Girls
Has anybody seen this show? It just ended it's first season a week or two ago. Thoughts? Types?
My take:
Hannah - ENTp
Marnie - Exxj
Shoshana - ?
Jessa - Ixxx
Adam - ISTj maybe?
Those types don't sound too out of the ballpark. I thought ILE for Hannah too but I wasn't too sure about it. Marnie is definitely a rational, not sure which one. She does seem sort of Se seeking though idk maybe that's simplifying her problems with her too soft bf on the show. EIE? Shoshana is almost too sort of stereotypical to type. Her character doesn't seem that well fleshed out. Jessa I could see as an irrational type, hard for me to pin down. Not sure on Adam. LSI could work I guess.
Other people like Marnie's bf: eh idk maybe SEI
his friend: ILE/SLE?
Girls (the tv show)
I can't express how much I love this show. There are no words.
Hannah Horvath
Marnie Michaels
Jessa Johansson
Shoshanna Shapiro
Thoughts?
@blackburry thought i would like it. i still haven't watched it. a couple trailers on youtube made it look okay.
i'm obviously no help but maybe bb will have ideas.
Holy moly I love this show.
Hannah- SEI
Marnie- ESE
Jessa- LSE
Shosanna- LII
Adam- ILE
Charlie- IEI
Ray- ILE
Elijah- ESE
Thomas-John- SLI
Booth Jonathon- IEI
Sandy- LSI
A show full of Gammas. Irresistible.
Girls are SEI and learn to grow up into responsible ESE mothers or IEI crackheads.
Ughhhhhh
But thanks blackburry for answering. Those are pretty good typings, for some reason it's hard for me to type them except for Hannah.
I don't think many of the characters in the show are Alpha, this is a fairlyvaluing show with
Some people watch horror movies until they can't take any more. Last year I watched the first season of this show.
These are pretty good (though I don't recognize a few of the names). I suggest the alternate typings:Originally Posted by blackburry
Hannah - ILE
Marnie - EIE
Ray - LII
Marnie could be EIE.
Ray could be ILE or LII.
Hannah's totally SEI. She comes off Ne bc she rambles all the damn time and goes off on tangents but everything she says is so simplistic, I just don't see any intuition function in her. Adam's sterotypical Fi-polr ILE.
Just bc it's about friendship doesn't make it delta-themed.
Besides there's mixed delta and alpha types in show. So.
Hannah- gamma?
Marnie- ESI
Jessa- beta?
Shosanna- SEI or ESE
Shoshanna is so amazing. I think I would bat for the other team when it comes to her.
boop. i just started watching this. i would like to hear how people type the characters so i know how to judge them.
For some reason they're pretty difficult to type (and this show was relevant ages ago : p).
Hannah - IEE
Adam - ILI
Charlie: EII
Ray - ILE
Shosanna - ESE
Marnie- EIE (or LSE)
Jessa - EP and not SEE
I agree with:
- Hannah as IEE (strong Delta NF vibes, but too comfortable with Se to be EII; more out there being hectic while an EII would sit back and listen more to her friends)
- Shoshanna as ESE (obviously extratim since she talks an insane amount without losing energy; very capable, very aware of her effect on others' feelings, says nice things/is very tactful, devastated by accidentally wearing white to a surprise wedding)
- Ray as Alpha NT, though I'd say LII over ILE since his Si seems pretty strong, he's not going around doing a million things, he used to be in philosophy grad school, loves kickin' back and reading, loves his peace and quiet, etc.
- Jessa as EP--my guess is SLE as she seems to have strong Se and weak Fi.
I don't think Marnie is an ethical type since any Fi/Fe ego would have known how much of a disaster singing at Charlie's startup celebration was going to be. I guess her vibe is more Delta ST to me than anything else. Not sure between LSE and SLI. Maybe LSE because she's more directive than most SLIs, but I feel like her goals are more SLI than LSE.
I don't have strong feelings about Charlie. My brain does not want to type him. Maybe that's a sign that he is EII and I don't want to admit it.He's not around too much though.
Adam is interesting. He spouts poetic stuff at random times. My gut has always said LSI for him, but he and Hannah don't feel like conflictors, so I'm not sure at all.
Hannah - IEE
Marnie - EJ
Shosanna - ESE
Jessa - SLE
Ray - ILE
I do not like this television show.
Lena Dunham is LSI imo or Beta at minimum but she was brought up by a really intense artist father (probably strong Ne lead) and I believe went to a Waldorf school. I don’t know if that makes her a creative subtype but she definitely thinks a lot of her artistic ability and tries to be an Ne type.
i believe the show’s characters are hardish to type because Lena’s writing is immature/aka not great. But yes Adam is ILE.
Reply With Quote
