-

Originally Posted by
pinoline
MBTI INFP= Fi + Ne
no
INFP = introversion + intuition + feeling (ethics) + perceiving (irrationality)
Jung's irrational type may to have only irrational function as main! What means Ni-Fe.
You may compare _direct_ descriptions of J/P and rationality/irrationality in Socionics (books, tests) - they are identical, they are compatible. MBT is not other typology - it's Jung's typology with a mistake.
Practically, as MBT followers use MBTI (which uses only preferences/dichotomies) as main typing way (with official recommendation to fit MBTI result in >70% cases), - the effect of that mistake is minimized and their types are lesser incorrect than'd could. And when they typed correctly(!) according to own preferences/dichotomies - they get always(!) correct Jung's type, which same in Socionics and anywhere.
To do that conversion it needs the situation:
1) MBT uses as main method direct typing by 8 functions, where they decide which are stronger and later by their incorrect model transform to preferences notation
2) Socionics has no compatible dichotomies theory which can be used directly
But we have other situation!
I think MBT have changed the Jung's functional model intentionally to overcome some copyright laws. Such they could to say "It's not Jung's typology - it's our special one". And now they keep this anachronism to "keep good face" that fooled people for tens of years.
Some idiots or bribed ones have implemented the idea that it needs to do strange conversion (like we'd had the said above conditions). The ones who get profit are MBT dudes who may to say that model in Socionics is "just other", overcoming the problem that MBT model is "just wrong". When people read Jung "Psychological Types" (instead of MBT bs) - they may notice that he used terms judging and rational / perceiving and irrational as synonyms! Also they understand the MBT idiocy when as leading function of judging types is said irrational function, what evidently contradicts to Jung.
If you were typed as INFP by MBTI and sure it's correct - then you should place IEI in your profile! Until you'll check your type by common socionics methods like through video + anket. I'm rather sure your type is not EII, but possibly IEI. It's not bad type, it's just other type which fits better to your behavior.
You may easily check are beta T types or delta T types give you more of psychic comfort with my examples in IR test theme. It's quickly.
The best would be also to create typing theme with your video. Then you'd got opinions of others too.
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules