Itsme, explain this!) Though I don’t think I’d get along with them very well in a relationship, for various reasons.
But yes, the uncomfortable feeling with supervisors is, I guess, probably a turnoff.
Re. subjectivity though, I think my personal preferences are the closest humanity’s yet come to obtaining objectivity on aesthetic matters. If what I prefer isn’t held as the ultimate arbiter of attractiveness, then it certainly ought to be.