Oooh, someone's butthurt...
Did you just forbid me from quoting you?
Why?
Alright then.
Alright, please be SPECIFIC. Post what you don't relate to and explain the gap between MBTI and Socionics description you don't relate to. Explain why you're Fe user in MBTI, but an Fi in socionics.
Please.
The fact that you are not doing that is the whole reason we're still writing.
Because all of those I saw certainly looked like they are exhibiting all INFP characteristics. =/
So MBTI saying you have high valuing personal ethic-based reasoning, that you're calm on the outside but passionate inside, that you're easily hurt doesn't suit you?
But Socionics saying you preffer intimate relationships not caring for wide circles of friends suits you?
Even though the same generalization is related to Fi users in MBTI, only not in function description, but in type description?
No I won't. But you have yet to state a SPECIFIC thing. Explain EXACTLY what makes you "not fit".
I know there's a difference and it seems to be this:
Socionics - Describes function Fi in terms of purely emotional interpersonal relationship preference effect it has on the user.
MBTI - Describes the function Fi in terms of intellectual process it represents in creating a person's value system + how it manifests in their behavior (as a generalisation).
MBTI is trying to assign a thinking process first and THEN show manifestation of it, Socionics is explaining the preference it causes, manifestation (behavior) and skill developed out of it (the thinking process).
Difference in thinking process:
MBTI - Internalized value system of idealism in emotion based individuality.
Socionics - Cognitive ability to tend to personal relationships in a superior manner.
Difference in manifestation:
MBTI - Doesn't show much emotion, internally more sensitive and passionate. This causes external understanding of others and thus attentiveness to outside ethics. Judgmental, self-centered assholes.
Socionics - Doesn't show much emotion, internally more sensitive and passionate. This causes external projection of others and thus attentiveness to outside emotions. Judgmental assholes.
Prefference:
MBTI - Smaller groups of intimate friends. Tend to be harder to open up.
Socionics - Intimate relationships and interaction they like to settle into.
Am I missing something here?
To me, based on what I'm seeing, MBTI and Socionics just walk the same path, in opposite directions, while disagreeing on what the traffic signs mean.
Whatever that Fi is TRULLY, that they are trying to describe from different observation points, they are just seeing and noting different parts of it, while claiming they see the rule behind it, and everything else is generalization.