let's type 15 of our new members

[Joy]

does anyone else think Hugo could be an ISTj?

[implied]

does anyone else think Hugo could be an ISTj?

that was my first guess on his type.

[Hugo]

Nah, he's ing waaay too much in the General section to be ISTj.

Too right!

[Joy]

Nah, he's ing waaay too much in the General section to be ISTj.

Too right!

that's not Ne

[anndelise]

He acts too much like other intj's when they get stuck in role mode.
And his controversial threads tend to be designed to open up perceptions with a point already being in mind. Much like a couple of other intjs on here.


btw joy....
by attempting to label him as istj while you yourself are "claiming" to be istj, are you suggestig that we identify you as being similar to him?

[Joy]

I'm not a gambling man... but I'd be willing to bet a year's salary that at least 1/3 of the people here who KNOW their types are wrong. There have been a lot of times when behavior was attributed to Ne when the person behind the behavior in fact had weak Ne.

I talked to a couple of other Ne types who agreed with me that Hugo has weak (or at least "improper") Ne. And it doesn't matter anyways! We're all amatuers! The only forum member that I know of that is not an amatuer is Dmitri. The rest of us have all of these socionics ideas that are based on poor understandings of articles translated from Russian, and worst of all, based on other forum members who very well could be typed entirely incorrectly. We really can't know anyone's type!

So to answer the question... No, I'm not saying that Hugo and I are similar.

[Hugo]

I talked to a couple of other Ne types who agreed with me that Hugo has weak (or at least "improper") Ne.

Who?

My Ne is very strong. At least back up why you think I have weak Ne. Give reasons.

[meatburger]

I think you make joy go weak at the kNees

lol