Disney Movies and Characters

[Gilly]

I'm well familiar with the story, as I'm not so dumb as to be utterly oblivious to the underlying themes and universality of the story (Cinderella stories have cropped up in basically every nation around the globe long before Disney had anything to do with it). You guys are just being way over-reactive, and I can't for the life of me understand why. Do you two have a personally vested interest in the story or what?

I'm not taking this seriously; if I'm passionate for any reason its because I relish the opportunity to make you look like the sheep that you are, slandering a fairy tale to get a one up in Ashton's book for being all capitalista. He has your brain and its funny because you're both seemingly oblivious to the effect. Or just bad liars.

That being said, I think at least Timmy and are on the same page even though we're on opposite "sides."

[Gilly]

Although Timmy is unfortunately retarded and hillariously and intentionally wrong in his reporting of "millions of impoverished " vs "billions of entitled." Lmfao.

[marooned]

I actually do see Cinderella as ESFj. But anyway not that I'm sure about this.

I think Pocahontas might be EXI.

[Galen]

I'm not taking this seriously; if I'm passionate for any reason its because I relish the opportunity to make you look like the sheep that you are, slandering a fairy tale to get a one up in Ashton's book for being all capitalista. He has your brain and its funny because you're both seemingly oblivious to the effect. Or just bad liars.

You're misinterpreting my intentions. I've been this sort of sarcastic all my life without the presence of Ashton.

[Gilly]

I don't question that. But you are putting it to his use.

[Gilly]

Or you just want to fuck him. Not really sure yet.

[Galen]

I don't question that. But you are putting it to his use.

What use?

Or you just want to fuck him. Not really sure yet.

oh no you found out my dirty secret

[bionic]

I came in here to find my glass slipper.... Does anyone know where it went? I need it before midnight!!!

[MisterNi]

I came in here to find my glass slipper.... Does anyone know where it went? I need it before midnight!!!

MisterNi is hoarding it and probably masturbated on it. He wants to Believe.

I did what now? Why're you dragging my name into this?

[WVBRY]

MisterNi is hoarding it and probably masturbated on it. He wants to Believe.

I did what now? Why're you dragging my name into this?

Because he cant let anything go these days.

[silverchris9]

Oh fuck this thread makes me want to vomit.


Stitch's poor impulse control combined with his strong attachment and open expression of need for other people makes me think SXE, leaning SEE over SLE. On the other hand, his playfulness implies Alpha/Beta over Gamma/Delta. I think it would be a very interesting and fruitful typing to see Stitch as SLE. The question is: what type is Lilo? I would say she's definitely an Fe type. And her sole vocation/is constant imitation, which to me points towards Beta NF. But alpha NF is very likely as well. I suppose IEE could even be possible.

I've never watched Pocahontas, but in my mind she's ESI. Or maybe my parents took me to see it and I hated it, possibly because it was a girl movie.

[717495]

What really does playfulness have to do with it? If SEE and playful, then SEE and playful.

[Pa3s]

Cinderella is every type who's always wanted to get something good out of life without ever actually trying.

While it is certainly not "fair" to apply our modern understanding of equality of oppurtinity and gender roles on this medieval/fantasy world, I agree that it might convey wrong values. Cinderella was born rich and then treated badly by her stepmother after her biological mother died. However, she can't help herself so she prays for help. From this point on, her (tedious) work is done by animals and she gets virtually everything she needs. And as you know, her goal is simply to marry the prince and live as an aristocrat. She did basically nothing to deserve this herself other than being treated badly.

It would have been way better if she broke free from her family (since her father did nothing to help her as well, apparently) and became successful because of her own work.

[717495]

It would have been way better if she broke free from her family (since her father did nothing to help her as well, apparently) and became successful because of her own work.

Now you're on to something. Then she kills them and steals the fairy grandmother's powers, then takes over the world.

[Pa3s]

Now you're on to something. Then she kills them and steals the fairy grandmother's powers, then takes over the world.

Exactly!

[neko]

Pokahontas - LSI
stitch - SEI
Cinderella - ESE

[Korpsy Knievel]

[Jenna]

Just watched beauty and the beast again and noticed I haven't added anything to this thread..
Belle is kind of typeless because she has no character flaws, but she seems like an IEI. I also think that having no character flaws is partially the reason so many types identify with her, as we are only getting a superficial view of her.

Me, the wife of that boorish, brainless . . .
"Madame Gaston!"
Can't you just see it?
"Madame Gaston!"
His "little wife", ugh! No sir!
Not me, I guarantee it
I want much more than this provincial life!
I want adventure in the great wide somewhere
I want it more than I can tell
And for once it might be grand
To have someone understand
I want so much more than they've got planned

this part really doesn't seem like something an Fi base would wish for. It seems Se seeking, plus being beta and wanting to be away from the delta town she is in. I think if she were Fi leading, she wouldn't have a problem with this lifestyle. I also don't think she supervises her father.

imo, the whole movie is beta's view of delta, but it's not obvious enough for deltas to dislike it. It also shows a preference for Ni Se over Ne Si, as Belle's ILE father is this wacky, clumsy inventor, and Mrs. Potts being the stereotypical ESE kind of overbearing mother. (she could also be SEI I suppose but I lean towards ESE) All of the other/main protagonists are beta - Belle, Beast, Lumiere, Cogsworth, and Chip. It makes sense for this to be seen from a beta perspective, with an IEI who is bored of the small town she lives in, frequently escaping and becoming enthralled by the stories she reads. Then because of the events that took place, she finds herself in a magic castle with talking household items. (ahem, 4 much?) The only problem being the beast, as he is keeping her prisoner and she is unable to see her father (and of course he's also very hot tempered).
SIDE NOTE!
The most questionable of the betas being belle and the beast, but why would the beast surround himself with Fe Ti types exclusively? He listens to their advice on how to advance the relationship with Belle.. I just really don't see an SLI listening to his quasi, conflictor, and supervisor on such matters, or choosing to keep these types as his only company. And the same goes for him being LSE, but instead it's his contrary, superego, and business.
/end side note


Lumiere - EIE
Cogsworth - LSI

These two definitely fit the Beta rational duality that some here have experienced or witnessed. Lumiere is almost the star of the show it seems lol. Be Our Guest seems like a showy beta song too. Also note the beta views of alpha when maurice came in the castle acting all careless and everything - I don't remember what he did to lumiere but I remember him twisting the crown behind cogsworth lol

Chip - IEI. I think he is Belle's identical, as he looks up to her, and was so upset about her leaving that he secretly came with when she left to see her father. And he possibly supervises his mom.. Not that it's very visible because he's so young but it was just a vague impression that he didn't take his mom very seriously when she reprimanded him.. Mostly I just think he's Belle's identical because of what I said before, and because he's obviously Fe creative.. SEI isn't totally ruled out but I doubt it.

Gaston - I'm surprised (well, kind of) at how few people here realize that this is how unhealthy LSEs act. The entire town is like deltaland and he's their hero and Belle is the only one who sees through him. Gaston is small minded and chauvinistic, which is how many LSEs can be - especially in the eyes of their conflictor.

Le Fou - IEE. Lets gaston walk all over him.. I would say EII because of that but he seems EP, especially Ne base.

Beast - beta ST




I'm going to add some quotes in and finish this later, I'm tired lol

[World Socionics]

UNDENIABLY the best example of an SEI in Disney has got to be Chien Po from Mulan. Yao is also a good example of an SLE and Ling ILE.

[World Socionics]

Mrs. Potts being the stereotypical ESE kind of overbearing mother. (she could also be SEI I suppose but I lean towards ESE) All of the other/main protagonists are beta - Belle, Beast, Lumiere, Cogsworth, and Chip.


Lumiere - EIE
Cogsworth - LSI

These two definitely fit the Beta rational duality that some here have experienced or witnessed. Lumiere is almost the star of the show it seems lol. Be Our Guest seems like a showy beta song too. Also note the beta views of alpha when maurice came in the castle acting all careless and everything - I don't remember what he did to lumiere but I remember him twisting the crown behind cogsworth lol

Chip - IEI. I think he is Belle's identical, as he looks up to her, and was so upset about her leaving that he secretly came with when she left to see her father. And he possibly supervises his mom.. Not that it's very visible because he's so young but it was just a vague impression that he didn't take his mom very seriously when she reprimanded him.. Mostly I just think he's Belle's identical because of what I said before, and because he's obviously Fe creative.. SEI isn't totally ruled out but I doubt it.

Gaston - I'm surprised (well, kind of) at how few people here realize that this is how unhealthy LSEs act. The entire town is like deltaland and he's their hero and Belle is the only one who sees through him. Gaston is small minded and chauvinistic, which is how many LSEs can be - especially in the eyes of their conflictor.

Le Fou - IEE. Lets gaston walk all over him.. I would say EII because of that but he seems EP, especially Ne base.

Beast - beta ST




I'm going to add some quotes in and finish this later, I'm tired lol

Projecting much?

Lumiere - ESE
Cogsworth - LIE

I have no idea why you think they're duals, they don't get along. It's their conflict that produces humour. Cogsworth shows far more evidence of Extraverted Logic than Introverted Logic. Indeed, I can't see any sign of internal principles that an LxI would have and he only wants to make sure the Beast isn't angered. At the same time, he is constantly trying to make sure everything is running efficiently, like clockwork even. With his Extraverted Ethics clearly assuming the Role form: 'If it's not Baroque, don't fix it' [laughs at his own joke] - the humour coming from him laughing at something without succeeding to amuse anyone else. Also he has trouble keeping a level head when his instructions aren't followed - a classic Te leading Fe role trait. He often puts on a strained smile when he thinks he ought to be friendly, indeed friendliness doesn't come naturally to him, however he does understand the need to try and act appropriately (Fi suggestive). Introverted Sensing is likely his Vulnerable point, him not seeing why Belle shouldn't have bread crusts and water for dinner. At the same time, he lacks the ability to assert himself adequately that Demonstrative or Creative Extraverted Sensing would bring, however he clearly aims to be so (Hidden Agenda) as seen in the battle scene in the castle when he dresses up as a pirate, gleefully wielding scissors and a gun suggesting that it is his Mobilising function instead. Perhaps you want to call him an LSI because he would be a stereotypical ISTJ in MBTI.

Big, jolly numbers would be just as Alpha as Beta. It's specifically a 'Merry' thing. I'd also argue Be Our Guest is more of an 'Alpha' song, given its 'Caregiver' theme. Lumiere is comforting and sensual in his manner, wanting to make sure everyone specifically has a good time, all the time rather than wanting to affect the mood for some long term goal. Certainly an Extraverted Ethics leading type as most people would agree, but Introverted Sensing strongly appears to be his creative. Notice he pays little importance to what time he is serving dinner (indeed, it's late at night) and simply notices that Belle needs to be fed. Introverted Intuition isn't being prioritised here in the slightest. (See how Cogsworth's Ni>Si conflicts with this). He's also far more in control of the situation than Cogsworth is, asserting himself in a way that comes across as likeable (simply shoves Cogsworth out of the way). This would be a good example of Demonstrative Extraverted Sensing over Cogsworth's Mobilising Se.

As for Ms Potts, I would argue SEI over ESE. Care for the young ones seems to take priority over affecting mood in any considerable way although I woudn't say she doesn't value it as well. She also happily takes a background role compared to Lumiere's exuberance. MBTI for her is likely ESFJ however, hence the confusion.

Chip as IEI? I see that very much actually.

[Radio]

Beast as Beta ST? No way. He's an LSE caricature, like Sully in Monster's Inc..

[willekeurig]

Me, the wife of that boorish, brainless . . .
"Madame Gaston!"
Can't you just see it?
"Madame Gaston!"
His "little wife", ugh! No sir!
Not me, I guarantee it
I want much more than this provincial life!
I want adventure in the great wide somewhere
I want it more than I can tell
And for once it might be grand
To have someone understand
I want so much more than they've got planned


this part really doesn't seem like something an Fi base would wish for. It seems Se seeking, plus being beta and wanting to be away from the delta town she is in.

Why not E4 Fi leading?

[Beautiful sky]

Snow White is INFj

[World Socionics]

Watching Beauty and the Beast again, it seems that the Beast is undoubtedly an LSE and Belle a very likely IEI. Gaston, on the other hand, seems more SLE than LSE. I wonder if a Disney miracle has been performed on Socionics.


On second thought, I would go back on what I have italicised. Although Belle seems to be showing plenty of Ni and Fe, this could still be Demonstrative and Ignoring. Also, her whole warming to Beast and rejection of Gaston is based on Fi-valuing and a very bad reaction to Gaston's Se attempt. EII is now my diagnosis of her, despite the clear 'Fe airbrushing' of Disney movies on the Serious quadras.

Plus, just look at how happy she is made comfy...'Be our Guest'. Si mobilising is quite possible.

[Beautiful sky]

Watching Beauty and the Beast again, it seems that the Beast is undoubtedly an LSE and Belle a very likely IEI. Gaston, on the other hand, seems more SLE than LSE. I wonder if a Disney miracle has been performed on Socionics.

LSE just don't display anger; he is worried that people are going to judge him and is negativist because he thinks that people will think he's ugly, that's a LSE trait; but, LSE are very funny, which he's not,

[World Socionics]

LSE just don't display anger; he is worried that people are going to judge him and is negativist because he thinks that people will think he's ugly, that's a LSE trait; but, LSE are very funny, which he's not,

http://www.wikisocion.org/en/index.p...averted_Ethics Nuhuh!

[Beautiful sky]

http://www.wikisocion.org/en/index.p...averted_Ethics Nuhuh!

I meant to say "don't only display" anger; they are hot tempered, believe me.

[Absurd]

Just believe her. Maritsa knows her duals inside out and even though they're beta NF, they're LSE.

[World Socionics]

I meant to say "don't only display" anger; they are hot tempered, believe me.

I see. So are you arguing that the Beast is LSE or is not?

[Beautiful sky]

I see. So are you arguing that the Beast is LSE or is not?

He could be; I described the traits that are consistent with it and not.

[World Socionics]

I see.

I've met LSEs that weren't funny at all. Many when in a mood to socialise might tell a joke and completely fail to amuse anyone, eventually laughing at it themselves. They might have a need to appear more easygoing than they actually are.

[Ver]

I watched Beauty and the Beast today; encouraged by the posts here. IMO Beauty is verly likely Delta NF and the Beast I could easily see as ESTj. But they could also be other types - we don't have as much insight into them as we should have . (apart from the fact that they are fictional)

[redbaron]

Walt Disney is IEI <3

[Beautiful sky]

I see.

I've met LSEs that weren't funny at all. Many when in a mood to socialise might tell a joke and completely fail to amuse anyone, eventually laughing at it themselves. They might have a need to appear more easygoing than they actually are.

LSE funny is sexual; joke about self deprecating, sarcasm,

[Saberstorm]

All Disney bad guys are outward manifestations of the evil side of Walt Disney himself. That is why they are all coy-faced ENFjs.

This looks like an ENFj:::



His facial expressions are identical to SCAR!

[Galen]

All Disney bad guys are outward manifestations of the evil side of Walt Disney himself. That is why they are all coy-faced ENFjs.

His facial expressions are identical to SCAR!

how on earth did you come to this conclusion

[Saberstorm]

He looks just like Scar. Talks like him too. Just insert Scar's dialouge into the interview. It would work.

Imagine Mister Disney saying this "life's not fair, well you see I, I will never be king," to a temp he is going to fire! It is totally Disney!

[Radio]

Walt Disney is IEI <3

thanks for confirming that you are horrible at typing people and that i should never take anything you say seriously.

[Radio]

You're an idiot. IEI is a very common typing for Walt Disney, n00b.

1. Um no, it's not.
2. Even if it were, it wouldn't be any more correct regardless of common consensus (which it isn't).
3. Nothing about Disney is Beta. The protagonists in Disney movies are almost always Delta (with the exception of Aladdin, which leans towards Alpha) and the villains are without exception all Beta.
4. lol

[fen]

I thought Walt Disney was IEE (?)