A lot of people are of the opinion that an MBTI INTJ is a socionics INTp and vice versa. Let's find it out by analyzing the descriptions in detail...
Ideas are an Alpha-NT domain. INTj is strategic wheras INTp is tactical.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
1:0
Confusing passage because they interpret Ni completely differently than in socionics. Again, ideas are INTj but applying instead of understanding concepts is INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
1:1
INTj is harder to understand than INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
2:1
INTj is strategic, INTp is tactical.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
3:1
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
3.5:1.5
INTj is clearly more arrogant and harder to understand.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
4.5:1.5
Business and efficiency are INTp.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
4.5:2.5
Hard to tell. Applies to both in a way.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
5:3
This point goes to the INTj who is Se-vulnerable, even though it might also apply to some INTps.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
6:3
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
6.5:3.5
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTJ
7:4
Conclusion
7:4 is not a very clear result but in my opinion it is rather a description of the type we know as Analyst in socionics.
Let's look at the INTP:
Analyze problems, identify patterns, logical explanations. Clearly INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0:1
Generate theories, enthusiasm, ignoring rules, new ideas. Definitely INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0:2
Depends on subtype.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
0.5:2.5
Definitely INTp. Constructivist, objectivist and Fe-vulnerable. INTj is emotivist, subjectivist and Fe is his dual-seeking function.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
1.5:2.5
Self-aggrandizement, social rebellion and creative potential are clearly INTj traits. The rest applies to both in a way so the point goes to the INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
1.5:3.5
Applies to both.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:4
Unconventional instead of traditional. INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:5
New thoughts are an Alpha domain. INTj.Originally Posted by personalitypage INTp
2:6
Conclusion
The INTJ scored 7:4 and the INTP even 6:2 as INTj. So both are Analysts and not Critics, probably with different subtypes. Maybe the guys on personalitypage are going to write a description of the socionics INTp-Critic soon...![]()


Reply With Quote



,
, etc.? Why cannot socionists use symbols Ne, Ni etc. as in MBTI? Just because they have somewhat different meaning. Socionics and MBTI, each in its own way, have slightly modified the original Jung's description of his 8 psychological types. For this reason,
(extraverted sensing) is first and foremost associated with control and expansion of personal space (which sometimes can manifest in excessive aagression, but often also manifests in a capability of managing lots of people and things).
