...
Printable View
...
oh god i hate these new-age romantic comedies about 20 somethings lol, my siblings are on this show like flies on shit
...
never seen it. Allysin Hannigan is hot though.
...
...
beta?
Barney --> Chandler M. Bing
Ted --> Dr Ross Geller
Marshall --> Joey Tribbiani
Lily --> Monica Geller
Robin --> Rachel Green / Phoebe Buffay / Regina Phalange
Ted: ILE
Robin: IEE
Barney: SLE or LIE
Marshall: SEI
Lily: ESE
Barney- ESE-SLE 7w8 > 3w4 > 8w7 sx/sp (ENTJ)
Ted- EII-IEE f9w8 > p6w5 > 3w4 sx/so (INFP)
Robin- ILE-SEE 7w8 > 4w3 > 8w9f sp/so (ENTP)
Marshall- SEI-ILE 2w3 > 1w9f > p6w7 so/sx (ESFP)
Lily- SEI-EIE 2w3 > f9w8 > 7w6p sx/so (ESFP)
Hola
Right so what type is Robyn?
Robin*
:lol:
I got Ted at ENTp(/INFp), and Barney at a highly caricatured ESTp(could be Ti subtype). Ted's type is uncertain cause of the +/- thing I keep talking about.
To me Barney is ESFj, Marshal ISFp, Lily ISFp, Ted INFj, Robin - maybe ENTj? I haven't seen much of show so I'm just playing a little bit with typings and basing them on some gut feeling I have.
Nah Barney's definitely ESTp. He's so transparent, you can point out the manifestations of Ego Ti in almost every episode.
Here's an example:
The Hot-Crazy Scale
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V9yRWs0zASg
Neil Patrick Harris: Te-ISTp
Everybody else: don't know, don't care
Lol.
Fixed.Quote:
Neil Patrick Harris: Gay, sexy, and man about it
Everybody else: don't know, don't care
You have to admit that was a pretty good burn.
Barney Stinson:
"There is only one reason to wait for one month: she is 17 years and 11 months"
bump for no reason.
Ted - Fi-INFj
Robin - Te-ISTp
Marshall - Fi-ENFp
Lily - Si-ISFp
Barney - not sure, not ESTp tho
Ted as ENTp is... weird. Where's the Ti valuing or Fi polr?
How incredibly odd. I was just viewing this thread before you bumped it.
Those seem like pretty good typings to me but why not ESTP for Barney?
Nah dude .yoo got it all wrong ..
Barney ==> ESTP
TED ==> INFJ
although i dnt knw marshall and lilly's type may be ESFJ/ESFP.. but im sure of the first too ..
Barney doesn't seem particularly Se-valuing to me.
Why N>S for Marshall?
Why do all unfunny, immature and crazy people have to be IEE's? I'm hoping they're not really like that IRL? I'm wondering because I find psychotic EIE's more appealing when it comes to first impressions.
But anway, I'm fairly certain Alyson Hannigan is SEI in this show. That's about the only one I'm very confident of. And you still didn't explain why SLE doesn't fit for barney :)
idk he's not really as direct as i expect ESTps to be. he's a lot more deliberate and conscious. he plans extensively before jumping into new situations, tries on elaborate alternate personas to score chicks, always has a back-up plan and consults the bro code frequently. he's always dressed in suits! lol. that sort of meticulousness strikes me as more alpha > beta. for comparison, see joey from friends who is an obvious ESTp imo.
When one of my friends was telling me about this show I said, "So it's basically a modern day Friends?"
I think Barney's more of a cross between Chandler and Joey. The man whore of the group.
And I cannot stand Ted. He's an annoying lame indecisive lying piece of shit. I enjoy all of the other characters though.
As far as typing them... I just don't see their characters as being realistic enough to type. Yes, Barney's got a focus on Ti, but he's too neurotic to type, truly. Robin's a MUCH better candidate for SLE than Barney. Marshall and Lily could possibly be identicals with her being more intelligent, but... he's a lawyer??? Really? What about his behavior indicates that he would be able to study and practice law all day and remain sane? Those two are great characters though. And Ted's just a piece of shit as previously mentioned.
:love:
Ran into too many dudes like that, who would rather emanate this fog of passive-aggressive mopey bullshit than take any action to fucking fix their shit or at least rage it out. Infuriating. Hell yeah on the Ted bashing. Ross was even worse, fucking hell...
Anyways, I got Lily as solid SEI, Robin as possible SLI, Ted as Ne Ego, Barney as xxTx, and Marshall as xxSp; past that, fuck if I know :lol:
I hated Ross on Friends. I've never seen this show but know some high schoolers who love it. lol
She ran into you at the grocery store :p
Ted ILE
Barney SLE
Marshall SEI
Lily ESE
Robin IEE
Chandler ILE
Monica ESE
Ross LII
Rachel SEI
Phoebe IEI
Joey SEE
Hannibal Smith LSE
BA Baracus ESE
HM Murdock ILE
Faceman Peck SEE?
Homer Simpson SEE
Marge Simpson EIE
Bart Simpson ILE? SLE?
Lisa Simpson EII
Tiffany LSI
George LII
Jennifer EIE
Samantha IEI
Charles SLI
Russell LSE
:p
:biggrin:
Do you lie a lot? If Ted didn't lie but instead had some noble quality, his indecisiveness could be forgiven. But because he lies, his strengths are not of adequate redeeming value in my eyes.
I like the Friends typings. I'm okay-ish (I still think they're too "fictional" to really have types) with the typings of the HIMYM characters with the exception of Robin. I see ST for her all the way. And while I can see an extreme focus on Se and Ti from Barney, I don't see him as an SLE. LSI is less troublesome, but it more seems like he's just too psycho to type.