School of Associative Socionics: Logics in Music

[Olga]

P.S. Please, help me to organise the threads into one folder or in any other appropriate way!

Extraverted Ego

Eminem - The Way I Am



Ego-Id:
Raper's delight (Sugarhill Gang)

[Olga]

Some of the country music and hard (?) rock:
Luke Bryan - Country Man


Nickelback-Learn The Hard Way (Выучи трудный путь)

[717495]

I think this is possibly Ti music? But I know an ESE who used to play this a lot (Ti seeking?).

Maybe not.

[717495]

Ne Ti

[Olga]

Thanks, very nice music especially the second one. I will post them into Russian forum and will tell you what ENTP Sandor thinks about it. It seems to me that he likes the lively music, metallic and rock. He found the music of Tereg which I percieve as intuitive and Ne - flegmatic. I was a bit surprised because I thought it was OK for Ne. But it also depends on the type and subtype of the person. If Sandor has Id-Ego oppositon, for example, then he would not see it as extraverted enough for Ne. Well then it may be your music will fit Ti, that would be also good. I personally think so.

[Singu]

I don't get it... why are Eminem's music considered Logical? By the way, I think that Eminem is IEI...

[Olga]

I don't get it... why are Eminem's music considered Logical? By the way, I think that Eminem is IEI...

Well... I think it is a bit information loaded approach to music. If it is highly emotional it sounds like a strong Ego music. Ego music in relation to temperament is choleric, nervous explicitly. It is also liniar in direction like somebody is hammering in order to get his point through. River Dance music is one of the good examples. You feel that the music is condenced and focused so that who ever gets it will have a full blow into one particular spot. The second example will be the song of the Russian singer. You will not understand the words but you can hear the rhythm or temperament of the music. And at the end it will be a quiet logical music, robot music. The logical music has either coold blooded style or business like style of music/texts.:

[Olga]

Compare with music which sounds to me as ethical and sincere in nature:



I think this music could be Fi+Ti. But may be somebody feels some other aspects here as well?

[Waddlesworth]

I never thought of this idea of "ego music" or "sincere" music etcetera. Interesting.