Originally Posted by
inumbra
i don't really see a point in trying to type "Ani" anymore. i can't stand eps i-iii for the most part and it was difficult for me to take interest in any of the characters since they were all pretty bad (imo). their relationships were terribly plot driven, unconvincing, uninteresting, and just lacked the sort of spark they were supposed to have. i personally suspect this was because george lucas exercised so much control over these films, and managed to unintentionally rob them of their soul. even reasonably good actors turned to bad ones under his direction.
some criticisms of relationships in eps i-iii (i'm focusing on this because interesting characters and meaningful relationships between them is often something i need to be in a story for me to really take interest in it...):
obi-wan & anakin
i was so disappointed in this relationship, and it was in part because of the expectations i had after watching eps iv-vi. old obi-wan described anakin as a good man who was a talented pilot when he first met him... and ultimately a good friend. he didn't tell luke *how* anakin was "seduced by the dark side of the force," but i got the impression whatever happened must have been incredibly complicated and horrifying--the process of turning this good man into an "agent of evil." this story is meaningful because we're comparing luke to his father throughout the films. luke is also a talented pilot and a good man, and a friend to obi-wan. obi-wan and yoda both fear that luke may go the way his father did *even though* luke seems like an incredibly compassionate and balanced person. obviously the lure of the dark side must be pretty powerful if it can turn someone like luke (and we imagine, like his father).
then in ep ii, we meet teenage ani who is a total rotten apple, imo. he already is more interested in power than he is in compassion or doing the right thing. he speaks of compassion as a virtue, but from the perspective of one who is lacking in it (which he is). although i wouldn't call him a bad person (yet), he is clearly not a "good person," imo. he is weak and flawed, and imo, NOT a good friend to obi-wan who he frequently defies and obviously disrespects. (i'll also set aside my huge disappointment that obi-wan first met anakin as a child, not as a man... and his "talents" at piloting referred to speed racing and accidentally destroying the droid-control ship... although yes he was really good at it considering he's a child... but we never get to meet the man *i* imagined anakin might have been... instead this kind of cliche, but also rather arrogant, child, and then teenager... ugh... i just can't continue).
anakin's turn to the dark side is both not very dramatic (it didn't hit the spot) since anakin wasn't that "good" of a "man" to begin with; and is kind of incomprehensible, and is best explained by him both lacking in compassion *and* being mentally retarded. a better defined relationship between anakin and palpatine could have fixed some of this, but unfortunately most of the relationships depicted in eps i-iii are poorly done.
palpatine & anakin
in eps i-iii, the drama of these is that palpatine has been influencing anakin from an early age and twisting his mind. we see very little of this, but it's implied. i would have liked to actually *see* it and have it be more complex... if anakin were ever a "good man" of at least reasonable intelligence, then palpatine would have had to put him through quite the psychological ringer to accomplish this. and *that* would have made for an intriguing relationship that i would have been interested in watching. unfortunately in ep. iii, anakin doesn't seem torn really at every turn, trying to sort out how he feels, or what the right thing to do is, or what is true/fiction, or what is real/fantasy... or any of the mental angst i would expect from a "good man" caught in the influence of a highly perceptive and manipulative evil man with better powers of foresight. (well, it is *kind of* there, but it's just so... unsatisfying...)
i thought using first the story of how ani lost his mother, followed by his fears of losing padme, compelling him to seek out the power of the dark side the jedi were keeping from him, was rather poorly done... not to mention, i just wish none of this had even been the story or the reason for him turning to the dark side.
i saw anakin as more of a near psychopath anyway who just needed a little push to go all the way there. he falls because he is psychologically weak, emotionally weak, easily led, and stupid. his separation from his mother as a child broke him, and he never recovered. even that could have been done in a better way, because i don't feel much about it. i feel like it was just poorly done, and i wanted a different story.
i don't know if this is the story i want, but i'd like this a little better: (and it's not even *that* different!)
the way to turn a "good person" to the dark side, especially vader as seen in eps. iv-vi, i think would involve palpatine convincing him of a better vision for the future. i liked the idea that the republic is broken and isn't working and that this is resulting in small wars and suffering. anakin as i imagined him (from what i knew of vader) probably had a couple of significant flaws: 1) he was ambitious--not to be confused with being arrogant--and wanted more than to be a pilot or jedi... he was interested in politics; 2) he had always been fond of order and truly believed that if they could restore order, all of the minor war and suffering would stop. in order to restore order though, one must rule with a tighter fist... there cannot be so much room for democracy and individual opinions, because nothing will ever be accomplished then and the conflicts will only grow worse.
palpatine inspires anakin as having the solution and the means to pull it off *if* he has help. gradually anakin becomes his helper, consumed by palpatine's vision, which *seems* to be driven by compassion, which for anakin at the time, is the only reason to do this. he knows that he is walking the line with being a criminal because palpatine doesn't care for the law--the republic has fallen too far to resolve anything through legal means. anakin is probably torn through most of this because he feels like he is doing the wrong thing, he's lying to friends like obi-wan, and to his wife (or lover, or whatever she is). he's constantly plagued by doubts and nightmares, but he trusts palpatine, who he believes to be a visionary and a good person.
it isn't until he's too deep in that he starts to realize there's more to palpatine than meets the eye--perhaps that he's even known for a while but never consciously could put his finger on it. eventually something less retarded than what happened in ep. iii occurs and anakin confronts palpatine with his suspicions, feeling like a paranoid lunatic as he does it. palpatine doesn't even try to lie to him, and is instead sincere and forthcoming. anakin feels betrayed nonetheless, but his bond with palpatine is too deep and the years he's spent aiding him make it seem there isn't any turning back. he wonders if he could do damage control and keep palpatine from doing too much evil, because the vision is still good. the republic is still in need. people are still suffering. despite the confrontation, their association doesn't end. (there was probably a temporary break due to anakin being pissed, but they come back together.)
anakin just gets in further over his head, trying to maintain some control, for he at least can make ethical decisions in all of this. he at least can try to do the right thing for the greatest number of people--and palpatine has been consistently honest when asked and willing to negotiate... but "the right thing" only gets more and more murky and more difficult to see and understand as time goes on, and palpatine only asks him to do increasingly unethical things in the name of a greater good, and sometimes anakin wonders if they'll ever reach this "greater good."
meanwhile his personal relationships other than with palpatine continue to deteriorate. he starts breaking off contact with people because he can't stand all the lying and deceit he's doing. they deserve better. he hurts his wife/lover and drives her away. it kills him to do this, but he can't see another way. the only person he can't quite seem to get rid of is his was-best-friend, obi-wan, who has an irritating ability to see right through him. he fears how much obi-wan may be able to figure out on his own--obi-wan was always the more perceptive of the two of them, and is a little older. obi-wan, who taught him much about the force, knows how anakin thinks... knows him intimately.
the more paranoid he gets about obi-wan getting to the bottom of things and not going away when he needs to (not taking a hint), the more angry anakin starts feeling towards him. palpatine eventually works his claws into the situation, and forces anakin to see that there is no way to succeed unless they deal with the obi-wan problem. it's another sacrifice "for the greater good."
this is probably what finally tears anakin apart. he betrayed all of his other friends, but they were all the better off for it. he could still tell himself he did the right thing. but to kill obi-wan, who has long been his best friend--that he can't convince himself is "right." unfortunately by this point, he's too far in, he's too warped, he's too internally conflicted, his emotions are too out of control--oscillating from paranoia to rage to something that isn't quite love anymore... all he can find relief in is the persistent cold of palpatine that offers a path out of this hell, if he can just endure long enough. so he chooses to trust palpatine, as he long has. he sees the good in palpatine. he knows that must be real... mustn't it?
when finally he confronts obi-wan, he chooses jedi combat, because that at least is fair. he takes no pleasure in this dark deed he must do. [...] and after, he lies to palpatine, telling him that he killed obi-wan. palpatine *appears* to believe him. either way, the obi-wan problem goes away. no one see obi-wan again.
anakin & padme
the most boring relationship ever, and one that makes little sense (to me). little ani is captivated by padme as a child because she's beautiful, good, and looks like an angel to him. being already an obsessive little creature he quickly develops a crush on her. when he sees who she really is--a powerful politician--he is further entranced. he holds onto his crush and then tries to make the moves on her in ep ii. she sees him as a little immature and remembers him as a kid, but the audience is supposed to believe that she gradually starts falling for him (really, in no time at all) through horrible dialog like "sand is hard and coarse, not soft like you" and "you're training to be a jedi and i'm... i'm a senator!" it makes no sense to me. by the end of the film she's declaring her undying love, and his obsession is secured to drive him through ep. iii.
obi-wan & anakin continued...
the dramatic end of this relationship was incredibly unsatisfying, both because i never really thought they had a very strong friendship as presented throughout the films, and because i had my own things i wanted to see (which i know isn't george lucas' fault).
for one (and this *is* lucas' fault), i really expected that anakin/vader took years hunting down the jedi himself because they were elusive, spread over multiple worlds, and difficult to kill (it was no job for storm troopers). since the jedi were so formidable, vader got badly cut up over time in these fights. he always won eventually, but the price was fingers and toes, arms and legs, etc. by the time he's finished his hard work, there's little left of him. the emperor, who i perceived as more of a paranoid and behind-the-scenes sort, naturally never lent a hand.
i did imagine there'd been a final confrontation with obi-wan, but i didn't believe it ended in obi-wan severing all of anakin's limbs himself. i personally thought obi-wan had probably lost the confrontation because anakin was stronger with the force (and not a total idiot). at most, it could have been a draw. in my most hopeful picture of this, anakin let obi-wan go out of some of the little compassion he still had since they had been such good friends. but i thought that might be too much to hope, and that maybe obi-wan, realizing he couldn't win and recently learning of anakin's offspring, had found a way to disappear in order to play the long game.
i imagined that other than yoda, obi-wan might have been the most elusive of all the jedi. he seemed to have a special talent for hiding and going unseen, one even anakin couldn't figure out. i remember at the end of ep. iv after vader has killed obi-wan, he seemed skeptical that he really had. i didn't think it was just how obi-wan's body vanished, which vader may have never seen such a thing before, but that he knows the old man has tricks up his sleeves and wants to be sure he's really gone this time.
anyway, i've went on enough about all of this.