Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Translation: Model A

  1. #1
    ._. Aiss's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    TIM
    IEI
    Posts
    2,015
    Mentioned
    19 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Default Translation: Model A

    Edit: an improved translation of this article is available at this link: http://www.the16types.info/vbulletin...lation-Model-A



    This is a (somehow improved) machine translation of an article from Russian wiki ("wikiznanie" - something like "wikiknow"). I found some interesting information on function dichotomies here, which is missing in English sources. Original: http://www.wikiznanie.ru/ru-wz/index.php/Модель_А

    Model A

    Model A - a model of human information processing, consisting of 8 functions, 4 strong and 4 weak. The model is named in honor of Aushra Augustinavichiute.


    Structure of the Model A
    The model is a set of eight mental functions distributed on 4 levels, or horizontal blocks, filled with eight aspects of information metabolism. It is a development of Jungian model.
    It was based on Freud's model of the psyche, consisting of three components: awareness (ego, "I"), conscience (?) (super-ego, superego) and the subconscious (id, "it"). Id from the Freud's model is divided into two blocks in the Model A: strong vital power, leaving behind a Freudian name - id, and weak vital - a super-id.

    Model A. 1, 3, 5, 7 - accepting functions, 2, 4, 6, 8 - producing functions; arrows next to dimension can define a sign of the function: ← - plus and asking (left), minus and declaring (right); → - plus and declaring (right), minus and asking (left). [I have no idea what Reinin dichotomy of asking/declaring could mean for functions, but the terms used here are identical to its name, so I kept them.]


    Functions Force
    Block
    Ring
    1
    2
    program creative strong ego
    base instrumental verbal "know"
    4-dimensional ← 3-dimensional → creative block
    Mental Ring
    4
    3
    mobilization role weak super-ego
    pain regulatory non-verbal "should"
    1-dimensional → 2-dimensional ← block of social control
    6
    5
    activation suggestive weak super-id
    referent instilled verbal "want"
    2-dimensional ← 1-dimensional → block of individual activities
    Vital Ring
    7
    8
    observation background strong ID
    restrictive demonstrative non-verbal "can"
    3-dimensional → 4-dimensional ← block of individual control
    Inert
    Contact
    Communication with the outside world



    (Note: The accepting and producing functions contradicts research. [1] But after the agreement between the authors, they soon settled) (???)

    Binary signs of the functions of model A
    Standard, each of the 8-function is characterized by three orthogonal binary features:
    1. strong - weak;
    2. mental - vital;
    3. accepting - producing.
    All functions of the model A can distinguish the following dichotomies:


    (+) (-) 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
    Strong Weak + + - - - - + +
    Mental Vital + + + + - - - -
    Accepting Producing + - + - + - + -
    Inert Contact + - - + - + + -
    Verbal Non-verbal + + - - + + - -
    Evaluational Situationary + - - + + - - +
    Exterior Interior + - + - - + - +





    • Strong (control) functions are in units of ego and id. This is zone of their own abilities. Embody the confidence and independence, the ability to operate continuously and efficiently. Our own view is more important than any other, it is to be spread in the surrounding world.
    • Weak (executive) functions are in blocks of super-ego and super-Id. This anti-conscience and the conscience of man, for him to adjust to the society. The zone of perpetual oscillation and uncertainty. Our own view is either absent or weak, so that people could easily be persuaded to another point of view.


    • Mental functions - belonging to to the mental (active) ring in model A. These functions are controlled by consciousness. The world and self is seen through these functions as if from outside, striving for objectivity and universality. The display impersonal, is embodied in verbal form, at the 2-y (?) signaling system.
    • Vital functions - belonging to the vital (passive) ring in model A. The functions of the subconscious, and conscious little control. The world is known through their own feelings and experiences, through the projection inside. For the vital functions are characterized by subjectivity, personal representation. The result is usually embodied in the activities through a second signal (?) system. The arguments go from first-person.


    • Accepting functions - learn about the world, they are the first in the blocks to receive information from the outside. Their task - to get a model of reality, their goal - an understanding that comes around.
    • Producing functions - means of changing reality. Being in a model after the accepting function, they find the solution of tasks set before them, so they do not reflect reality, as accepting, and generate a distorted picture of an imaginary world, which is a solution of their tasks.


    • Inert (reference) functions - rather rigid in their work, they are almost immune to internal changes. They require an external impulse of sufficient strength to them that something has changed. They are characterized by fairly long response, and often commit the state to which led the external impact. Thus they tend towards relative permanence.
    • Contact functions are very mobile and able to well manage their internal state. Through them a primary reaction to the impact from the outside happens (?). They produce an initial processing of information received, they also generate a final decision. Thus, their activity is determined by what happens around or current tasks, among which they can easily switch.


    • Verbal (discursive) functions (or overvalued) belong to clusters of ego and super-Id. They provide the active exchange of information between people, information on these functions is interesting, and easily discussed. They tend to desire self-development.
    • Non-verbal (working, cooperative) functions belong to the blocks of super-ego and id. Aspects of these functions are not negotiable, prefers mutual affair. Activity is limited to immediate needs and demands of society.


    • Evaluation functions - inert mental ring functions and contact functions of vital ring. Through them the score is a man people (mental inert), and the expectation of evaluation itself from others (vital contact) (?). And these estimates are slightly susceptible to change.
    • Situational functions - contact functions of the mental ring and inert of the vital ring. These functions, by contrast, are characterized by adjustment to the current situation, and avoidance of grade other (?). In contrast, estimates put only specific actions.


    • Exterior (continued) - accepting functions of the mental ring and producing functions of the vital ring. Functions that contain aspects of one color, black or white for extroverts and introverts respectively. Their primary characteristic is to consider relevant aspects of the invariable essence of the world, and strive to leave it in the form in which it is. External changes are perceived as inevitable but unusual.
    • Interior (variable) - producing functions of the mental ring and accepting of the vital ring. These functions tend to see aspects of their elements which should be changed in the first place. They are either actively influencing the world or passively expecting changes in it.

    The dimensionality of the functions of the Model A
    The notion of dimensionality of functions was introduced by Boukalov in 1989 by analogy with the dimension of functions in mathematics, then this concept was used by Yermak, Vladimir Davidovich. According to him, the manifestations of the functions of model A may be adequate to experience, norms, situations and time.

    Name
    Dim.
    Adequacy
    1 Program 4 experience, the norm, the situation now
    2 Creative 3 experience, the norm, the situation
    3 Role 2 experience, the norm
    4 Pain 1 experience
    5 Suggestive 1 experience
    6 Activation 2 experience, the norm
    7 Observation 3 experience, the norm, the situation
    8 Background 4 experience, the norm, the situation now



    1 - Ex (Eng. Experience) All functions can accumulate and use your own experience. Functions owning only experience (pain, suggestive) often are inadequate to the situation, if they don't know it from experience. Vera Novikova introduced the concept of mode of perception of information. Perception of information on these functions is in the mode of the past. Reaction functions are often inadequate to the situation, understanding of the situation comes later, often a long time when the relevance is lost.
    2 - Nr (Eng. Norm) Norms possess all functions except pain and suggestive. Use rules - social rules (etiquette), rules, laws, strange experience. Measure rule determines susceptibility to function just as valid in other situations. Novikov mode of perception - a static present. The reaction on the current situation, without calculating the possible consequences.
    3 - St (Eng. Situation) Situation possess all the strong features. They are able to develop new solutions to effectively use the exceptions to the rules, generalize patterns - to generate new knowledge and experience. Novikov mode of perception - the dynamic present. Actions on the situation in the light of trends and possible developments.
    4 - Tm. (Eng. Time) Time belongs only to program and background functions. The reaction is linked to time: reaction to a similar situation in a different time may have been different, estimates vary. Novikov mode of perception - the future. Prediction of the situation, action to forestall, for the future, ability to think in a virtual time scale.

    Signs of functions of model A
    The concept of sign functions is widely used by Yermak, although Victor Gulenko introduced them. Yermak defines signs as "quality", "scale" "orientation" and "distance" of functions.
    Signs of the functions define the following four properties of functions:
    1. Quality
    • "+" Maximizing the positive. Competence only in the field of positive properties. Avoidance, fear of negative.
    • "-" Priority to the care of the negative. Competence in the field of positive and negative.

    2. Magnitude
    • "+" Close Up, locality, the detail in the limited area of competence.
    • "-" The general plan, globality, universality.

    3. Orientation
    • "+" Inside, in the area of responsibility. Protecting yours.
    • "-" Out, capturing new influences.

    4. Distance
    • "+" A close psychological distance.
    • "-" Distant psychological distance. (?)


    Mental Ring
    Mental ring contains the functions responsible for social activity. The work of these functions are well understood.

    Ego block
    Also called a creative block, or block "know", or "adult" block. On this block remains the most social activity, a strong unit, so people in its operation believe that it is ready to defend their views and interests. This is the block on which the person meets the needs of society.
    Functions:
    • 1st: a program - mental strong acceptance;
    • 2nd: creative - mental strong productive.


    Super-ego block
    Otherwise: unit of social control, the unit "must." Weak block, through it social environment presents their demands to the individual, who is forced to comply with these requirements. Since the functions are of perceived weakness, the person attaches great importance to the development, filling it.
    Functions:
    • 3rd: role - mental weak acceptance;
    • 4th: pain - mental weak productive.


    Vital ring
    Vital ring consists of the functions responsible for the individual needs of man. They appear usually unconsciously.

    Super-id block
    It's also called a block of individual activity, block "want". Through this block people present their demands to society. Block is weak and unconscious, so it can be easily manipulated by others. An individual can actively exercise activities, but it's complex and takes long. The unit also lends itself to filling, so the part may look quite strong.
    Functions:
    • 5th: suggestive - vital weak acceptance;
    • 6th: activation - vital weak productive.


    Id block
    ... or the individual unit of control, block "can". Also meets the needs of the individual, but such that it can provide itself, as a relatively strong unit. Individual can show activity in this block for quite long, and usually in silence and alone, without seeking to exchange information.
    Functions:
    • 7th: observation - vital an acceptance;
    • 8th: background - the vital strong productive.


    Completing the Model A

    Aspects
    Model A is filled with eight aspects of the information metabolism:
    1. internal static body - black intuition, intuition of opportunities;
    2. external static body - black sensing, volitional sensing;
    3. external dynamics of the body - black logic, business logic;
    4. internal dynamics of the body - black ethics, ethics of emotions;
    5. internal dynamics of the field - white intuition, the intuition of time;
    6. external dynamics of the field - white sensing, sensing sensations; (?)
    7. external static field - white logic, the structural logic;
    8. internal static field - white ethics, ethics of relations.

    Principles of Model A
    1. The principle of displacement. Functions that differ only on grounds of vitality, mentality contain aspects that differ only in sign of the body-field. (Function in the mental ring replaces a similar function with a different color in the vital)
    2. Principle of additions. Functions that differ only in sign of accepting-producing, complement each other. (perceiving, who judge) (?)
    3. The principle of uniformity. Functions that differ only by strength, differ only on the basis of form-content aspects. (?)

    Model A for each TIM (TIM - Type of Information Metabolism)
    Structure of the Model A for each of TIM, the signs of the functions specified by Yermak. [Mental and vital ring elements have reversed signs within each quadra.]

    For example, for ILE:

    ILE
    + -
    - +
    + -
    - +


    Structure of the Model A for each of the TIM, signs are shown on the work Tsypina "Encyclopedia of relations." [What is known on this forum as "+/- quadra elements".]

    ILE SEI ESE LII
    + - + - - + - +
    - + - + + - + -
    - + - + + - + -
    + - + - - + - +
    EIE LSI SLE IEI
    + - + - - + - +
    - + - + + - + -
    - + - + + - + -
    + - + - - + - +
    SEE ILI LIE ESI
    + - + - - + - +
    - + - + + - + -
    - + - + + - + -
    + - + - - + - +
    LSE EII IEE SLI
    + - + - - + - +
    - + - + + - + -
    - + - + + - + -
    + - + - - + - +




    Work of Model A

    (→) 1 2
    Mental Ring
    (←) 4 3
    (←) 6 5
    Vital Ring
    (→) 7 8



    The order of the functions of the model A is a consensus among socionists. To some extent, the standard is described in the works of Augustinavichiute diagram showing the transfer of information on the rings (the mental and vital) consecutively in the order 1 → 2 → 3 → 4 → 1 and 5 → 6 → 7 → 8 → 5. Accordingly, the main entry point for incoming information are role-playing and suggestive functions, exit points - creative and background, that is, information exchange with the outside world "meets" all the contact function.
    Last edited by silke; 12-13-2013 at 10:45 AM. Reason: added link

  2. #2
    Coldest of the Socion EyeSeeCold's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Holy Temple of St. Augusta
    Posts
    3,693
    Mentioned
    5 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Default

    1.) Mental/Vital Groups:
    ILE, LII, LSI, SLE, SEE, ESI, EII, IEE
    SEI, ESE, EIE, IEI, ILI, LIE, LSE, SLI

    The orientation is Static/Dynamic.

    2.) Accepting/Producing Groups:

    LII, ESE, LSI, EIE, ESI, LIE, EII, LSE
    ILE, SEI, SLE, IEI, SEE, ILI, IEE, SLI

    The orientation is Rational/Irrational.

    3.) Strong/Weak Groups:
    LII, ILE, ILI, LIE ; SEI, ESE, ESI, SEE
    LSI, SLE, SLI, LSE ; IEI, EIE, EII, IEE

    The orientation is by Club.

    4.) Inert/Contact
    LII, SEI, LIE, SEE ; ESE, ILE, ESI, ILI
    LSI, IEI, LSE, IEE ; EIE, SLE, EII, SLI

    The orientation is by ?????

    5.) Valued/Subdued Groups.
    LII, ESE, SEI, ILE ; LSI, EIE, IEI, SLE
    ILI, SEE, ESI, LIE ; SLI, IEE, EII, LSE

    The orientation is by Quadra.

    6.) Evaluatory/Situational
    LII, ESE, ILI, SEE ; LSI, EIE, SLI, IEE
    ESI, LIE, SEI, ILE ; EII, LSE, IEI, SLE

    The orientation is by ?????

    7.) Bold/Cautious
    LII, SEI, ILI, ESI ; LSI, IEI, SLI, EII
    ILE, ESE, LIE, SEE ; SLE, EIE, LSE, IEE

    Mobilization Small Group.



    Carefree/Farsighted and Yielding/Obstinate are likely the unknown ones.
    Last edited by EyeSeeCold; 09-21-2011 at 08:20 AM.
    (i)NTFS

    An ILI at rest tends to remain at rest
    and an ILI in motion is probably not an ILI

    31.9FM KICE Radio ♫ *56K Warning*
    My work on Inert/Contact subtypes

    Socionics Visual Identification(V.I.) Database
    Socionics Tests Database
    Comprehensive List of Socionics Sites


    Fidei Defensor

  3. #3
    Haikus Beautiful sky's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    EII land
    TIM
    EII INFj
    Posts
    22,740
    Mentioned
    531 Post(s)
    Tagged
    6 Thread(s)

    Default

    OMG; these are the kinds of things, refereed to as Cold Logic, that types like myself have a hard time digesting. Where's the human/personal element? LOL

  4. #4
    ._. Aiss's Avatar
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    TIM
    IEI
    Posts
    2,015
    Mentioned
    19 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by EyeSeeCold View Post
    4.) Inert/Contact
    LII, SEI, LIE, SEE ; ESE, ILE, ESI, ILI
    LSI, IEI, LSE, IEE ; EIE, SLE, EII, SLI

    The orientation is by ?????
    6.) Evaluatory/Situational
    LII, ESE, ILI, SEE ; LSI, EIE, SLI, IEE
    ESI, LIE, SEI, ILE ; EII, LSE, IEI, SLE

    The orientation is by ?????
    Carefree/Farsighted and Yielding/Obstinate are likely the unknown ones.
    IMO it's a better idea to define type dichotomies such as Tactical/Strategic, Constructivist/Emotivist, Carefree/Farsighted and Yielding/Obstinate through functions dichotomies.

    Tactics is Contact Sensing (and Inert Intuition).
    Strategy is Contact Intuition (and Inert Sensing).

    Constructivism is Contact Logic (and Inert Ethics).
    Emotivism is Contact Ethics (and Inert Logic).

    Carefreeness is Evaluatory Si/Ne (and Situationary Se/Ni).
    Farsightedness is Evaluatory Se/Ni (and Situationary Si/Ne).

    Yielding is Evaluatory Te/Fi (and Situationary Ti/Fe).
    Obstinacy is Evaluatory Ti/Fe (and Situationary Te/Fi).

    I put the other aspects in brackets because while I think they're equally important, Reinin dichotomies as we know them seem to focus solely on the former. The rationale for it is probably that Contact and Evaluatory functions are respectively more likely to result in observable traits, and to an extent I agree with it. Yet this is probably at least part of the reason those descriptions are far from accurate and not exactly fitting many types. Another thing is that there's no differentiation between strong and week, or accepting and producing functions, which makes any non-vague description off for some types.

    For example, Tacticians are said to prefer tactics over strategy because they make contact with the environment primarily through Sensing and not through Intuition. And most descriptions of tactical types focus on contact through strong producing sensing (essentially, they match Sj types). Similarly, strategy is pictured so as to fit Nj types primarily. The dichotomy seems to be broken to an extent for Np (contact but weak and accepting Sensing) and Sp types (contact but weak and accepting Intuition). They match the basic idea behind this division, but the moment descriptions get more specific (which people constantly demand), it stops working for all. In effect, Smilingeyes' description, which differentiates between Rational and Irrational Tacticians and Strategists, does an overall better job of conveying the idea behind this dichotomy.

  5. #5
    Coldest of the Socion EyeSeeCold's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Holy Temple of St. Augusta
    Posts
    3,693
    Mentioned
    5 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Default

    Quote Originally Posted by Aiss View Post
    IMO it's a better idea to define type dichotomies such as Tactical/Strategic, Constructivist/Emotivist, Carefree/Farsighted and Yielding/Obstinate through functions dichotomies.

    Tactics is Contact Sensing (and Inert Intuition).
    Strategy is Contact Intuition (and Inert Sensing).

    Constructivism is Contact Logic (and Inert Ethics).
    Emotivism is Contact Ethics (and Inert Logic).

    Carefreeness is Evaluatory Si/Ne (and Situationary Se/Ni).
    Farsightedness is Evaluatory Se/Ni (and Situationary Si/Ne).

    Yielding is Evaluatory Te/Fi (and Situationary Ti/Fe).
    Obstinacy is Evaluatory Ti/Fe (and Situationary Te/Fi).
    I see, maybe that's why these groups were different from the first few. Wondering about Bold/Cautious too, though on Wikisocion it states: "For extroverts, all extroverted elements are Bold functions, and all introverted elements Cautious. Conversely, introverts have Bold introverted functions and Cautious extroverted functions."

    Extraverted Boldness, Extraverted Cautiousness
    Introverted Boldness, Introverted Cautiousness


    I give special concern to the dichotomies you worked with because those seem to be the least accounted for.

    I put the other aspects in brackets because while I think they're equally important, Reinin dichotomies as we know them seem to focus solely on the former. The rationale for it is probably that Contact and Evaluatory functions are respectively more likely to result in observable traits, and to an extent I agree with it. Yet this is probably at least part of the reason those descriptions are far from accurate and not exactly fitting many types. Another thing is that there's no differentiation between strong and week, or accepting and producing functions, which makes any non-vague description off for some types.

    For example, Tacticians are said to prefer tactics over strategy because they make contact with the environment primarily through Sensing and not through Intuition. And most descriptions of tactical types focus on contact through strong producing sensing (essentially, they match Sj types). Similarly, strategy is pictured so as to fit Nj types primarily. The dichotomy seems to be broken to an extent for Np (contact but weak and accepting Sensing) and Sp types (contact but weak and accepting Intuition). They match the basic idea behind this division, but the moment descriptions get more specific (which people constantly demand), it stops working for all. In effect, Smilingeyes' description, which differentiates between Rational and Irrational Tacticians and Strategists, does an overall better job of conveying the idea behind this dichotomy.
    This makes sense, I noticed a similar thing happening with TeFi/FeTi aka Serious/Merry and SeNi/NeSi aka Decisive/Judicious(or Central/Peripheral). I'm interested in these again so I will read up on it.


    As an aside, I was thinking that maybe subtype could be justified, found, or otherwise differentiated through the function dichotomies.

    The 1st function is: Accepting, Inert, Evaluatory and Bold.
    The 2nd function is: Producing, Contact, Situational and Cautious.
    (i)NTFS

    An ILI at rest tends to remain at rest
    and an ILI in motion is probably not an ILI

    31.9FM KICE Radio ♫ *56K Warning*
    My work on Inert/Contact subtypes

    Socionics Visual Identification(V.I.) Database
    Socionics Tests Database
    Comprehensive List of Socionics Sites


    Fidei Defensor

  6. #6
    Coldest of the Socion EyeSeeCold's Avatar
    Join Date
    Oct 2010
    Location
    Holy Temple of St. Augusta
    Posts
    3,693
    Mentioned
    5 Post(s)
    Tagged
    0 Thread(s)

    Default

    The Russians did something similar.

    Interesting that they termed Bold/Cautious as External/Internal.

    Extraverts have External , Internal
    Introverts have External , Internal
    (i)NTFS

    An ILI at rest tends to remain at rest
    and an ILI in motion is probably not an ILI

    31.9FM KICE Radio ♫ *56K Warning*
    My work on Inert/Contact subtypes

    Socionics Visual Identification(V.I.) Database
    Socionics Tests Database
    Comprehensive List of Socionics Sites


    Fidei Defensor

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •