Typings

[Gilly]

khamelion - IEI-Fe
UDP - LSI-Ti (possibly LII)
kamangir - IEI-Fe
anamericancer - SLE-Ti
jessica - LSI
implied - Se/Ni, leaning IEI (since my recovery from momentary insanity)
Ezra - SLE
LokiVanguard - SEI
SunshineLively/Blaze - SLE-Ti
heath - LSI
hitta - LSI
normal - IEI
munenori - SEI

No it is not a coincidence that these are all (except mune) Betas.

And believe me, there is more to come.

[hellothere]

oooh controversy.

This one has to be the strangest:

LokiVanguard - IEI

why do you think that's the case? Unless you meant Loki...

wait, is this a list of people you like (because you're also Beta?)?

[Phaedrus]

Hitta is definitely not an LSI. That's an absurd suggestion. Haven't you seen his video? Your V.I. skills haven't deteriorated that much, have they?

[normal]

Agree.

[Gilly]

No it is not just a list of people I "like."

Yes I am serious about hitta as LSI, and no I do not think it is absurd in any way. The only other possible types I could see would be IEI or LII.

[Gilly]

Added one. Thanks for reminding me, norm :wink:

[Gilly]

Edit: holding on to this one for a while.

[Gilly]

I mean whichever Loki is consistently on Stickam.

[Expat]

khamelion - IEI-Fe

I'm inclined to see SEE as more likely.

implied - Se of some kind, currently leaning SLE

I very much doubt it. If she's some Se ego type, then I'd say ESI.

I don't necessarily agree with your other typings, either.

[Gilly]

Somehow I didn't think you would agree with at least a few of these. I am trying to depart from traditional typing methods and simply use my impressions, which have been most reliable for me in real life, as opposed to detailed analysis (which, IMO, seems to lead more to confusion than anything). I am not 100% on any of them, although Kelly's type is the most obvious to me of those presented. I am also fairly certain of Kamangir. With Ezra I am mostly confident of SLE. Implied seems definitely Se-subtype of something to me, although Beta NF is still possible IMO. Heath and hitta I am fairly set on. UDP is in the air for me but it's one of the two listed. Allie seems Se>Ne to me, and I think niffweed had similar observations (although I wasn't sure his verbalized rationale was very strong). Normal has a lot of VI characteristics that I associate with IEIs from what I remember. Jessica seems, above all, IxTx and, Se valuing. Munenori as SEI is mostly a vague impression, as is Loki.

[Joy]

Kelly doesn't have a Te PoLR.

[Gilly]

I don't really care what you think

[Creepy-Cyclops]

I think they're interesting G-Star. Ever had any impression of mine?

[Gilly]

Nope.

[Expat]

I've always agreed with Se-Ni quadra for Jessica, which is why I suggested ILI rather than SLI some time ago.

However, more recently, I'm inclined to go for SLE (which of course means that LSI is also plausible). I think she may be a SLE who became "introverted" due to growing up in a low-Se environment.

[aestrivex]

implied - Se of some kind, currently leaning SLE

what the fuck do you think you're smoking?

[Joy]

However, more recently, I'm inclined to go for SLE (which of course means that LSI is also plausible). I think she may be a SLE who became "introverted" due to growing up in a low-Se environment.

I agree.

[Gilly]

Why do you think irrationality is more evident than introversion?

[implied]

I very much doubt it. If she's some Se ego type, then I'd say ESI.

I don't necessarily agree with your other typings, either.

i probably agree with you. honestly, i can't see myself as other Se ego types aside from ESI perhaps. i think ESTp and ISTj are both sort of laughable, heh. i also think extroversion -- although i can act rather extroverted sometimes -- is laughable.

Implied seems definitely Se-subtype of something to me, although Beta NF is still possible IMO.

ONLY 13 MORE TO GUESS.

[UDP]

I don't really care what you think

Well, imagine I, or Joy, went about making threads telling you what your type was.

[Joy]

Why do you think irrationality is more evident than introversion?

Yes.


There's no way she has an IJ temperament (unless she portrays herself extremely inaccurately). And a Fi PoLR makes a whole lot more sense than a Ne PoLR (and Fi Role).

Is it really so hard to imagine an extrovert being reclusive?

Well, imagine I, or Joy, went about making threads telling you what your type was.

He'd enjoy it.

[xyz]

I gotta admit mine came outta left field.

[jessica129]

I'm really very frustrated when people keep bringing this up. I've said it a million and one times that i exaggerate nearly everything when I come here and that obviously i seem more SLE here than i do IRL. Had any of you met me in real life, you'd never, ever say SLE again...I mean, it's almost laughable.

I can identify with with some aspects of it, but in general, you can't really be a social butterfly or life of the party and outgoing when you're shy and really just doesn't like people all that much. And aren't SLE's go-getters and enthusiastic? HAH. Maybe i'm basing this off the MBTI descriptions too much but when i think of an SLE, I think confident, outgoing, acheivers, popular, life of the party, etc....and well, those are nothing like me. But i do find INFP's incredibly hawt so maybe it's true. I really don't think i'm ISTP either but what the hell, i'm tired of trying to find one that fits.

[Joy]

I can identify with with some aspects of it, but in general, you can't really be a social butterfly or life of the party and outgoing when you're shy and really just doesn't like people all that much. And aren't SLE's go-getters and enthusiastic? HAH... I think confident, outgoing, acheivers, popular, life of the party, etc....

No.

(That is, I'm sure there are SLE's similar to what you described, but this is not a picture of a "typical" SLE... and you wouldn't even be a typical one anyways.)

Maybe i'm basing this off the MBTI descriptions too much but when i think of an SLE.

Yes.

[Gilly]

Well, imagine I, or Joy, went about making threads telling you what your type was.

I would probably listen and at least pretend be interested because I have a massive ego and love it when people talk about me.

However I fail to grasp the relevance of this to what is being discussed here. I said nothing about Joy's type (although I do have many thoughts, as she well knows). And I happen to know Kelly fairly well (perhaps not as well as Joy, but I do know her personally), which neither you nor Joy can claim of me (although I feel that Joy does have some idea of what I'm about; you just feel threatened by me, as far as I can tell).

[Gilly]

There's no way she has an IJ temperament (unless she portrays herself extremely inaccurately). And a Fi PoLR makes a whole lot more sense than a Ne PoLR (and Fi Role).

Perhaps. But I don't buy any of this bullshit about Peter "supervising" her; he is just trying on his latest ideological pants and telling people that their morals are out of style. He was the immoral king of irreverence this time last year or so.

Is it really so hard to imagine an extrovert being reclusive?

No, but I just see her lacking Fe most clearly. Perhaps SLE-Ti. I will think about this.

[strrrng]

GILLY GILLY PLEASE TYPE ME!!! USE YOUR NEWFOUND BUDDHISM SKILLS TO GET A GESTALT IMPRESSION OF ME


I'm curious what your typing of me is, considering how OFF the typings on that list are lol

[Gilly]

IEI works just fine.

[strrrng]

IEI works just fine.

alright, cool.

[munenori2]

Interesting list there, Gilly. The beta ranks are growing!

[jessica129]

estp/istj is looking a little more promising for me after I did some digging and reading the different quadra characteristics. Maybe i'm easily influenced. Who knows.

[strrrng]

khamelion - IEI-Fe prolly...she seems to have the emotional accessibility of Fe-valuers
UDP - LSI-Ti (possibly LII) doesn't seem aggressive or "there" enough to be Se ego
kamangir - IEI-Fe dunno him well enough
anamericancer - SLE-Ti the fuck? she's you, except just more spacey lol
jessica - LSI dunno, doesn't seem to have Fe though
implied - Se of some kind, currently leaning SLE IMPLIED YOU'RE MY F-ING DUAL!!!
Ezra - SLE LOLZ no comment
LokiVanguard - IEI honestly lol...wtf?
SunshineLively/Blaze - SLE-Ti dunno
heath - LSI from what I've seen, he's too laid back to be IJ
hitta - LSI lol, hitta is the epitome of an INTj too engulfed in theoretical abstraction
normal - IEI dunno
munenori - SEI nah. doesn't like Fe and Se is very vulnerable for him

how did you go about typing these people?

[Phaedrus]

Yes I am serious about hitta as LSI, and no I do not think it is absurd in any way. The only other possible types I could see would be IEI or LII.

Which means that you haven't seen his video. He is not an LSI. If you had seen his video you would agree on that.

[normal]

I think I could be IEI actually.

[Ms. Kensington]

Maybe i'm easily influenced. Who knows.

i think ISTps are easily influenced, at least by me

[Gilly]

Which means that you haven't seen his video. He is not an LSI. If you had seen his video you would agree on that.

Actually I have seen his videos, and have observed him on cam multiple times. Now please go away. You are inordinately bothersome.


@Nick: My typings are solely based on my general perceptions and impressions of people, as well as their resemblance to my "benchmark" people IRL.

lol, how is Allie at all like me? I am not 100% on her, but I do think she's a Ti type of some kind, and I believe that I am not.

[Gilly]

Hitta looks like Chrisopher Hitchens, ftr.

[strrrng]

lol, how is Allie at all like me? I am not 100% on her, but I do think she's a Ti type of some kind, and I believe that I am not.

you both have that ENTp zaniness. this may seem like an oversimplification, but I think it's a direct manifestation of Ne+Fe and the EP temperament. Obviously those two functions are more emphasized with her than you, and your goofiness isn't entirely socionics-related lol, but I see the same temperament there. Plus, I can sense an ESTp a mile away lol, no joke...I've conversed with her a lot and I basically never got the Se I so desperately seek lol

And what type do you think you are atm?

[Gilly]

EIE

[olduser]

I am probably LSI or LII or ILE. I think this list is good. Although I think Lokivanguard may be a Delta NF.