So... am I really ISFj or ESFp?Originally Posted by thehotelambush's description of me that he sent to a few people via private message
Or am I ESTp like Dee suggested?
Or am I ENTp like I and everyone else has thought so far? Just wondering...
Anyone agree to this?
So... am I really ISFj or ESFp?
Or am I ESTp like Dee suggested?
Or am I ENTp like I and everyone else has thought so far? Just wondering...
maybe a saint is just a dead prick with a good publicist
maybe tommorow's statues are insecure without their foes
go ask the frog what the scorpion knows
.
Is it okay with him that you post that?
my own subjective observation from the one time I heard you in a stickam chat was that you were loud and confident and very sharp in a similar way to how Khamelion was. It kind of intimidated me. But then I don't know whether this is anything more than you being EP, or if it is even related to socionics at all. Just to be clear though, despite finding your presence in the chat slightly intimidating, from what little I know of you (through your forum posts), I respect most of your views (that thread about the death penalty comes to mind), so I hope you don't take this the wrong way!
This little girl can intimidate you guys?
hence the
Oops.
I should ask first.
I asked him on Stickam just now, and he said yes.
Late, but I did it!
This was flattering in a weird way. Why am I flattered????my own subjective observation from the one time I heard you in a stickam chat was that you were loud and confident and very sharp in a similar way to how Khamelion was. It kind of intimidated me
maybe a saint is just a dead prick with a good publicist
maybe tommorow's statues are insecure without their foes
go ask the frog what the scorpion knows
I've always thought you were ISFj personally.
D-SEI9w1
This is me and my dual being scientific together
FTR, I gave an argument in Allie's thread that I created a while ago for why she is not SEE, which included some reasoning as to why she is ILE.
I think she clearly has a preference for Alpha atmosphere, conversation and jokes over Gamma ones. As a side point, has anyone ever considered Alpha SF?
She does this only when being attacked. In fact, Allie reciprocates feelings of others in a very mechanistic way. For example, if I express my undying love for her, she'll be like "awww thanks, Ezra"; she responds in the "appropriate way". This to me chimes weak Fi, valued Fe. This kind of joking she has where she'll say "I love Ezra today" or "we are duals only today" is - to me - a kind of nonchalant way of expressing herself. She doesn't really consider the deeper meanings of anything anyone says as I would expect an ethical type to do; it's as if she has an unawareness of anything beyond what people "actually say". I'm not talking about this in context of "hidden meanings" in "things", but rather in the caes of people and relationships. What I'm trying to say is that based on these cases, I've built up a mental picture of how she'd react in other ways in life, and it makes most sense to me.
a) That wasn't me and b) was said random person on cam or just typing?She and Ashton (or Ezra, maybe, I can't remember) were talking at length about whether some random person that came into the chatroom looked male or female (gay or straight?), which to me clearly is all about Se - picking up on the details of a person's external appearance.
This is all speculation, and I disagree with it. Also, it contradicts the above. How can she be both standoffish and confrontational?She also has this kind of stand-offish way of communicating, like she's intentionally suppressing expression of her emotions to tone down the atmosphere (id Fe). But at the same time she finds ways to subtly express her attraction, repulsion, or disgust with other people (ego Fi).
Consider Leon, an ethical type in his reasoning. Basically, if you give him even the slightest rationale, he'll probably agree with you. Now compare him to what Allie has just done. She doesn't readily accept this, because she recognises that what you are telling her is - to her - based on absolutely nothing. Said concrete observable data isn't just unobservable and not concrete; it doesn't actually exist in her mind. So of course you'd expect her to do what she did, and I don't think it's conclusive evidence that points towards any type.When I suggested Gamma SF was not such a bad suggestion, she immediately took it personally and demanded that I give evidence. I said she had said lots of SeFi stuff, but I couldn't remember exactly what. (She gave me a really hard time for this, which I think has to do with valued Se and Te - expecting me to communicate with very concrete observable data.)
No, I disagree. It could just be an unwillingness to discuss at that particular time for a myriad of possible reaons. And what happened to "She gave me a really hard time for this, which I think has to do with valued Se and Te - expecting me to communicate with very concrete observable data"? If she can't provide it, why does that make her Se and Te if you, an LII, can't provide it?I eventually pointed out that it often seems like she's bragging ("I'm all the types"), even if it is just a joke, which it usually is. In response she had zero arguments for ILE, and in my opinion barely even tried ("Well, it's just, you know, I'm more Ne and Ti than Se and Fi"). Very good evidence for Super-Ego Ti, or even PoLR.
You should talk about yourself more.
Oh wait, what's that?
You don't want to?
Well now, Alpha.
On a serious note, out of pure interest, this is the kind of thing I tend to do. I know if people will suggest things I will argue against it, but I will always throw it out there as a possibility on the forum. In thehotelambush's defence, this could be a sign of weak Ti and weak but valued Te for Allie. It's kind of an insecurity in one's own conclusion to maul another's argument which stands up against one's own (valued Ti), or - alternatively - a true strength in being able to consider others' arguments (valued Te). Yet another possibility is that this is Ne valuing; considering all these different possibilities.
Good arguments.
LIS.
A curious combination of fear and respect. You are a true ******.
How did you reach this conclusion?
Right, I can see what you're getting at, and if this is Fi, this is another thing to add to the reasoning as to why I am SLE and not SEE. However, ignoring the wiki for a moment, do you think it is Fi?
Yeah, I agree.
I'm not Fi dominant.
maybe a saint is just a dead prick with a good publicist
maybe tommorow's statues are insecure without their foes
go ask the frog what the scorpion knows
Laughing In Silence.
Laughing out loud, really? I never knew that one!
Allie easily strikes me as intuitive, infantile, and alpha > sensory, aggressor, and gamma.
Posts I wrote in the past contain less nuance.
If you're in this forum to learn something, be careful. Lots of misplaced toxicity.
~an extraverted consciousness is unable to believe in invisible forces.
~a certain mysterious power that may prove terribly fascinating to the extraverted man, for it touches his unconscious.
I think some of the arguments for weak Fi are valid, but ultimately insignificant given what I have observed.
Please elaborate. Examples of Allie's jokes:
"i'm tired of loving people, I'm going to start hating people now"
"i wanna get my 72 virgins"
"i'm not a racist - i'll eat anybody"
allieoxenbee: SERIOUSLY
allieoxenbee: STAY OFF CAMERA BITCHES
allieoxenbee: i want only them <33
thehotelambush: what was the context of this?: "i want only them <33"
allieoxenbee: cause anyone else on there would fuck up my quadra, man!
-in reference to wanting a full Alpha quadra on camera
allieoxenbee: i love kicking people
Which is exactly how strong and subdued Fe appears to a Ti type.She does this only when being attacked. In fact, Allie reciprocates feelings of others in a very mechanistic way. For example, if I express my undying love for her, she'll be like "awww thanks, Ezra"; she responds in the "appropriate way".
A very good argument for weak intuition.This to me chimes weak Fi, valued Fe. This kind of joking she has where she'll say "I love Ezra today" or "we are duals only today" is - to me - a kind of nonchalant way of expressing herself. She doesn't really consider the deeper meanings of anything anyone says as I would expect an ethical type to do; it's as if she has an unawareness of anything beyond what people "actually say". I'm not talking about this in context of "hidden meanings" in "things", but rather in the caes of people and relationships.
On cam.was said random person on cam or just typing?
She was expecting me to give her evidence without coming up with any of her own. I was speculating that the type of evidence she expected points to Se and Te values - though I admit I really couldn't come up with anything at the time. Allie still hasn't justified her self-typing, so it has nothing to do with "the particular time".No, I disagree. It could just be an unwillingness to discuss at that particular time for a myriad of possible reaons. And what happened to "She gave me a really hard time for this, which I think has to do with valued Se and Te - expecting me to communicate with very concrete observable data"? If she can't provide it, why does that make her Se and Te if you, an LII, can't provide it?
The notion that Allie is a gamma SF is simply retarted - no more, no less. This thread shouldn't even have been created lol. Just because some people don't understand that overly specific behaviors which depend entirely on context don't point to functions doesn't mean we should go doubting peoples' types. Allie is probably one of the best examples of an Ne-ENTp.
Do you think you could possibly say something constructive instead of just dismissing it out of hand?
What about the people he had PMed? (If he sent that PM to them but not you, that is.)
Bleh, anyways... I'm not giving a type opinion here, just asking a question: If the top choices are ILE and SEE, why aren't more people suggesting that SLE is a possibility?
Now for my opinion: She seems Fe/Ti > Te/Fi.
The attention that's put on eating and resting in people's interactions with her (that I've seen) suggests that she has weak Si. I haven't seen enough to decide whether I think it makes more sense in her super ego or super id, but I don't think that it makes sense as her 7th function (because someone with Si for their 7th function wouldn't have much patience with those types of suggestions).
There is nothing to be said; this notion is fatuous. I have interacted with her quite a bit, which is why I seem so adamant. I could maybe accept an argument for ENFp or something, but not the exact opposite of her true type.
*headdesk*
What do you think of this, thehotelambush?
In what ways does she pay attention to it? Do you have any examples? Over the course of many hours I have personally seen far more attention given to Se: objectively observable qualities of things rather than her subjective state of well-being and relationship with her physical surroundings.
This would make sense if Se was conscious and Si was not, but that's not what I was talking about. I was referring to how other people focus on Si in the things they say to her (you should eat, you need to sleep more than that, etc.), and how she doesn't snap at them for it (at least not that I've seen).
It sounds like most of the people here have had far more time interacting with and observing her than me though.
She is constantly attuned to the Fe atmosphere. She pays very great attention to indirect subtleties in this area, which I believe help her maintain that external emotional flow. Her Ne is also very apparent, as she seems to drift from idea to idea, constantly seeking out things. Additionally, EP is the only plausible temperament. I think people like steve and riddy could clarify not only how her behavior is one of the best examples of this temperament, but how they identify with her, in regards to communication styles and how they illustrate ideas.
*bullshit*
still ISFj for me *yawn*
D-SEI
This is me and my dual being scientific together
I don't think they're insignificant at all. I guess here is a disagreement which will clearly lead to disagreement.
In my eyes, all this points towards is that she's Fe valuing.Please elaborate. Examples of Allie's jokes:
"i'm tired of loving people, I'm going to start hating people now"
"i wanna get my 72 virgins"
"i'm not a racist - i'll eat anybody"
allieoxenbee: SERIOUSLY
allieoxenbee: STAY OFF CAMERA BITCHES
allieoxenbee: i want only them <33
thehotelambush: what was the context of this?: "i want only them <33"
allieoxenbee: cause anyone else on there would fuck up my quadra, man!
-in reference to wanting a full Alpha quadra on camera
allieoxenbee: i love kicking people
I'm not sure it is. I see it as the way in which any type who is weak in Fe would react. They're just responding in the way that is "acceptable".Which is exactly how strong and subdued Fe appears to a Ti type.
That's how I thought you might minsterpret it. I was considering the ethical meaning behind a given sentence; not the conceptual meaning, as an intuitive type would.A very good argument for weak intuition.
Right, I can't really answer for this. However, keep in mind that it is an isolated case.On cam.
Right, she's just confused.She was expecting me to give her evidence without coming up with any of her own. I was speculating that the type of evidence she expected points to Se and Te values - though I admit I really couldn't come up with anything at the time. Allie still hasn't justified her self-typing, so it has nothing to do with "the particular time".
ILE makes sense. I really doubt ESI.
EIE, ENFj, intuitive subtype.
E3 (probably 3w4)
Cool ILI hubbys are better than LSIs any time!
Old blog: http://firsttimeinusa.blogspot.com/
New blog: http://having-a-kid.blogspot.com/
Yes.Why the hell do people even consider ESI to be an option??
IJ, especially, seems distant for Allie.
Posts I wrote in the past contain less nuance.
If you're in this forum to learn something, be careful. Lots of misplaced toxicity.
~an extraverted consciousness is unable to believe in invisible forces.
~a certain mysterious power that may prove terribly fascinating to the extraverted man, for it touches his unconscious.
LOL I know. That's why this thread is so STUPID.
I agree.
They're been discussing this in Stickam for an hour now.
Gilly and Dee think I'm beta.
I could see this.
maybe a saint is just a dead prick with a good publicist
maybe tommorow's statues are insecure without their foes
go ask the frog what the scorpion knows
What beta type?
ENFj?
ESTp?
Posts I wrote in the past contain less nuance.
If you're in this forum to learn something, be careful. Lots of misplaced toxicity.
~an extraverted consciousness is unable to believe in invisible forces.
~a certain mysterious power that may prove terribly fascinating to the extraverted man, for it touches his unconscious.
That's what I was thinking, though I think SLE is the least likely type.
same.
btw allie!
maybe a saint is just a dead prick with a good publicist
maybe tommorow's statues are insecure without their foes
go ask the frog what the scorpion knows
fuck you, allie's a tiger
or a racoon.
I never cease to marvel at the potency of collective stupidity. Allie, do you honestly think you're beta, given all of our interactions? I mean, quite frankly, I seek ESTps who rape me, so to speak...I think I would know if you were giving me Se lol. Or are they notioning that you're ENFj? God, this is such idiocy.
jesus I think she's INTp now.
D-SEI
This is me and my dual being scientific together
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
