Rick : ENFJ
Herzy : ISTJ
Ezra : ESTJ
Niffweed17 : INTP
Joy : INTJ
Tcaud : INTP
Bionicgoat : ESFP
FDG : ESFP
Expat : INTJ
Kristiina : ENFP
Liveandletlive : ESFJ
UDP : ESTJ
Possible MBTI Types of Forum Members
Rick : ENFJ
Herzy : ISTJ
Ezra : ESTJ
Niffweed17 : INTP
Joy : INTJ
Tcaud : INTP
Bionicgoat : ESFP
FDG : ESFP
Expat : INTJ
Kristiina : ENFP
Liveandletlive : ESFJ
UDP : ESTJ
*shrug* why not?
, LIE, ENTj logical subtype, 8w9 sx/sp
Originally Posted by implied
sounds pretty spot on.
6w5 sx
model Φ: -+0
sloan - rcuei
Sounds pretty much almost totally wrong.
Rick is totally ENFP, Ezra could be ESTJ, niffweed is totally INTP (that one is correct), Joy is most likely not INTJ, Tcaud is totally INTJ, Bionicgoat is totally ISFP, FDG is most likely not ESFP, Expat is absolutely not INTJ, Kristiina is most likely not ENFP, what type Livenadletlive is I don't know, and UDP could be ESTJ.
I don't know people well enough to argue any of these either way. However, could you give evidence supporting why they're not and what you believe they are? It'd be helpful.
Johari/Nohari
"Tell someone you love them today, because life is short; shout it at them in German, because life is also terrifying."
Fruit, the fluffy kitty.
some corrections. not that i have any real idea.
I test ENTP in M-B anyway. I like the description and find it rather fitting. Only a seriously unhealthy person would relate to most MBTI ENTJ descriptions.
Obsequium amicos, veritas odium parit
lol
i think if FDG is TOTALLY TOTALLY mbti something, maybe being TOTALLY ENTJ or TOTALLY ESTP works well. ezra could easily be TOTALLY mbti ESTJ, i would not balk at the suggestion that he's TOTALLY ENTJ like niffweed has offered. why is expat ABSOLUTELY NOT INTJ?
6w5 sx
model Φ: -+0
sloan - rcuei
Yeah, I've often thought that. There was once a guy in YouTube who said he was an ENTJ; a total weirdo.
@niffweed: INFP for Rick works well, I think.
Because I'm Absolutely Fabulous, not Absolutely INTJ.
this guy?
6w5 sx
model Φ: -+0
sloan - rcuei
Yeah, the same.this guy?
He reminds me of the "subway ghost" in Ghost.
Totally got AbFab stuck in my head now, even though I didn't watch much at all of it... I just remember the show.
INFj
9w1 sp/sx
i get the idea that he probably sat in his room all day taking bong hits and then his roommate or some friend was like, "DUDE, WANNA TAKE THE MBTI? DUDE, POST A VIDEO ON SIMILARMINDS. DUDE, HOW DO YOU WORK THIS CAMERA?" fwiw, gilly gave me a similar impression in the webchat.
6w5 sx
model Φ: -+0
sloan - rcuei
In person he's a pussy-cat.
I don't know many of them well but there is a statistical improbability that FDG is an MBTI ESFP. It is very rare you'd see them on a personality typing site for any period of time. It's just not the type of thing the MBTI ESFPs are into usually.
I've read Joy and Expat's posts for quite awhile though and I can see INTJ.
Polly
ENTP
lol I'm the biggest fail SF ever
Last edited by bg; 03-12-2008 at 01:42 AM. Reason: the voices!!!
Just for the fun of it.
dolphin: ESFP
liveandletlive: ESFP
Diana: ISTJ
Mea: INFP
Eunice: ISFP
Niffweed: INTP
Implied: INTP
Bionicgoat: ISFP
Salawa: INFP
Munenori: ENFJ
Jessica: ESTP
Hkkmr: ENTP
TheBlueBlade: INFP
Scarlettlux: INFJ
I love ya like a fat kid loves cake Eunice, but I just can't see how we're that much alike (this seems to keep coming up) Maybe I need to step back and look at myself to see it.
FWIW the two things I ALWAYS test as (and that descriptively make sense) in MBTT are I and J.
ISTP.
“Whether we fall by ambition, blood, or lust, like diamonds we are cut with our own dust.”
I think I encountered Herzy at a forum towards the end of my Myers-Briggs days (N-Cen for the record - I think Rocky was there too), at which point she called herself ESTP. Not sure if she meant Socionics ESTp or not, but I could see ESTP Myers-Briggsian. I was INTP by MBTI.
Retired from posting and drawing Social Security. E-mail or PM to contact.
I pity your souls
What bullshit. You've not got a fucking clue.
The first MBTI test I took said I was INFJ, and I related to the description at the time. However, I was extremely unhealthy (this was towards the end of my year long misadventure with too much adderall) and unhappy (this was towards the end of a miserable marriage) at the time. I think though that the reason I related to the INFJ descriptions was because of the Indigo in me.
I took a test.
Your Type is
INTJ
Introverted 33%
Intuitive 100%
Thinking 50%
Judging 22%
These are the kinds of results I get. Usually the J/P preference is not very strong because of the "J" questions like "is your desk tidy" etc.
Last edited by Expat; 03-12-2008 at 05:15 PM.
Yeah. And I definitely prefer a "quiet family atmosphere" to a party.
I remember seeing in some other forum (similarminds perhaps) some talk about this particular video and how it was meant as some kind of parody or joke or something and they mocked our forum for taking it so seriously.
What's their, or your, definition of "taking it so seriously"?
My self-perceived online tests MBTI path:
INTJ ---> INTX ---> INXX ---> INTP/INXP ---> INFP
(none of the descriptions really ever worked)
I think I test as a J when I'm feeling organized
I test as a P when I'm feeling cluttered
I test as a T when I'm not feeling much of anything
I test as an F when I'm feeling a lot
So really, it's more just INXX.
Why? Being an F type is not about feelings. Do you really understand these dichotomies correctly?
It's the test questions... the way I answer the questions changes depending upon how I'm feeling at the time.
Why? Don't you know what you are like most of the time in most situations? That's what you are instructed to consider when you answer the test questions. If your answers change depending on your current mode, your are not answering them correctly.
ENTJ's are total R0X0RZ!!!!
I don't think it's that simple. I tend to be rather changeable (within limits). How I am most of the time, is not always an easy question to answer.
I can't remember nor did I really understand it all. But the point seemed to be that the video was some sort of joke more than a real typing video. If that was not the case then I have misunderstood something. They seemed to criticize this forum for being too elitist and were a bit confused about socionics relationship to MBTI.
Anyways, I think the person in the video is the member "Kyle" from similarminds:
http://similarminds.com/forums/profi...wprofile&u=285
Though I am not 100% sure. It seems Rocky would know him well as he posts there often (is it the same Rocky?)
I don't know his socionics type but a quick look at his posts seemed a bit Feish and possibly intuitive. I really have no clear opinion.
Elitist? Rubbish. Only people who are too stupid, ugly, or weak to participate in this forum would even think that it's elitist. We don't need such rabble here.
¬.¬ I seem to be detecting elitism. However, having been on that forum, I have seen people who thought socionics was bull. I think it's the lack of tangible proof, somewhat, although the fact that it works should seem to be proof enough IMO.
Johari/Nohari
"Tell someone you love them today, because life is short; shout it at them in German, because life is also terrifying."
Fruit, the fluffy kitty.
I think that's the point.
I'm pretty sure I'm both INFj and INFJ, though in MB I can vacillate between F & T and J & P.
Oh, to find you in dreams - mixing prior, analog, and never-beens... facts slip and turn and change with little lucidity. except the strong, permeating reality of emotion.
I'm still ESTJ when I test in MBTI.
Reply With Quote
