Gwen Stefani

[machintruc]

I'm thinking of EIE.

[eunice]

I really like her. She's awesome.

[emeye]

i mean that one i know was like stuck up on health diet and whatnot. kinda pitied her a little. i mean healthy eating is good, but not like being so fucking all over it like.

ENTj because of healthy food? Either I have misunderstood something, or someone has no idea about Si PoLR impact.

[Vilzu]

I don't think she's EIE or even beta.

[Kristiina]

I don't think she's EIE or even beta.

I agree. She does look rather gamma though. She certainly has the Se-valuing body language... She looks a little bit like Madonna on a couple of pics. The same kind of badass-arrogant in a good way. Can she be the same type as Madonna?

[misutii]

I don't think she's EIE or even beta.

I think I see where you're coming from here. I'm positive she's NF though. She has the general NF "all over the place" image thing going. ENFp maybe

[Creepy-Cyclops]

I think she VI's like ENFp.

I don't think we can take her diet too much into consideration. Many celebs have unusual eating habits to try to stay thin, irrespective of type.

[misutii]

She looks a little bit like Madonna on a couple of pics. The same kind of badass-arrogant in a good way. Can she be the same type as Madonna?

not completely sure, but gwen seems alot softer, like madonna would easily kick her ass in a catfight on top of tables at a bar and do it without spilling her drink

[Kristiina]

not completely sure, but gwen seems alot softer, like madonna would easily kick her ass in a catfight on top of tables at a bar and do it without spilling her drink

haha, true dat! She would give a good fight before she goes down! But yeah, she would be threatening to hit and Madonna would use the weak moment to give a quick and effective hit that determines the winner.

[machintruc]

I agree. She does look rather gamma though. She certainly has the Se-valuing body language... She looks a little bit like Madonna on a couple of pics. The same kind of badass-arrogant in a good way. Can she be the same type as Madonna?

I think Madonna is SEE.

Besides, LIE's and EIE's may be quite rednecky.

[dbmmama]

She is so hot and cool! What's her type?

Love,
Kelly Jo

[Creepy-bg]

She is so hot and cool! What's her type?

Love,
Kelly Jo

I don't know but one of my bestfriends says the same thing... she also like glitter... go figure

[Ms. Kensington]

I think she's ISFp.

[machintruc]

I think, she's some pushy-looking -+0 EII.

[marooned]

Lol. I wanted to post "the history of where we had gotten with this before." I didn't mean it as any "rebuff" or anything... I don't care if we start ten new threads on Gwen Stefani (or anyone). I thought it might be helpful to have the "whole picture" *cough* of what our collective brainpower has come up with.

You know, in all honesty, she looks Beta NF to me... EIE. And she makes fascinating music videos that are really quirky and unusual that seem to create whole new worlds. It seems sort of . But you know, that sort of thing isn't exclusively . I wouldn't rule out Alpha. Bah. I'll stop now.

[dbmmama]

Lol. I wanted to post "the history of where we had gotten with this before." I didn't mean it as any "rebuff" or anything... I don't care if we start ten new threads on Gwen Stefani (or anyone). I thought it might be helpful to have the "whole picture" *cough* of what our collective brainpower has come up with.

You know, in all honesty, she looks Beta NF to me... EIE. And she makes fascinating music videos that are really quirky and unusual that seem to create whole new worlds. It seems sort of . But you know, that sort of thing isn't exclusively . I wouldn't rule out Alpha. Bah. I'll stop now.

loki,

i truly appreciated you posting it. i was actually "trying" to not be hard on myself for not thinking of looking in the archives first.

lv
kj

[Blaze]

i love her.

to me she seems SEI.

[Khola aka Bee]

She is SEI because I said so, I'm SEI and I have seen her IRL.

We have similar tastes in fashion, looool! ^_^

[Exodus]

She is clearly very physically confident, and likes to personally cultivate her appearance. SEE. - or failing that, SLE.

'I try not to be but I'm super-neurotic about diet,' she says. 'I'm neurotic about trying not to be neurotic! I'm like every other girl. I have to try really hard my whole life to try to be fit. And I'm super-vain. And I want to wear cute clothes. You know, I was chubby when I was a little girl. And I have all those issues everyone else has. But I try not to. And I've learnt over the years that it's such a waste of time. And people like me whether I'm a little bit fatter or not.'
...
Like her music, her style is sexy but also out there - eclectic, almost aggressive. She's no victim, and certainly no fashion victim. With someone like Victoria Beckham, you can see that a stylist has decided what she's going to wear and put it together piece by piece, but Gwen's style always seems organic

http://lifeandhealth.guardian.co.uk/...139305,00.html

[dbmmama]

Oh...but her fashion is clone to my beta heart. <3

ditto that. she is one of my absolute favs!

[ScarlettLux]

Whatever she is, she's such a 3w4.

[FDG]

I totally can't stand her.

[Blaze]

I agree. Compare her to SEI Britney Spears. There's more Beta-kinky.

do you really think so? britney seems totally SEE to me. total EP temperament, impulsive, Fi creative.

gwen, in the letterman interview has that alpha openness and is clearly more Fe. i think SEI's can come across as extremely confident and assertive. i'm sure she's had to develop that being in show business, too.

[Blaze]

I totally can't stand her.

more evidence of SEI if we believe that FDG is LIE, that is.

[Blaze]

I think understanding what Britney is would certainly help type her.

looking at lyrics help i think. when i think about one of her early songs, Oops, I Did it Again, to me this seems sort of Fi creative. since i don't connect along the lines of Ne with her, i deduce SEE. just my opinion though.

[ScanDave]

looking at lyrics help i think. when i think about one of her early songs, Oops, I Did it Again, to me this seems sort of Fi creative. since i don't connect along the lines of Ne with her, i deduce SEE. just my opinion though.

She did not write that song.

Also if you look at interviews she is way too calm and relaxed to be EP temperament.

As far her being impulsive; she was not always on drugs like that. Or whatever mental issues she going through.

Spears is SEI. As is Stefani. You have to look past the image that has been created around them.

Old interview of Stefani before she got famous.



I think she is quite SEI here.

[Exodus]

Because she's being artistic? All the things she's talking about are objective - where she's from, what material the costume is made of, how expensive the material was, who the band is working with, etc. - Se and Te. Very little about her subjective state and reactions. Also, when the interviewer acts her if she is excited about the show her response is "Yes, I'm excited."

[strrrng]

she's Ni-ENFj 3w4 - too raw to be Fe subtype. what britney is is irrelevant.

[ScanDave]

Because she's being artistic? All the things she's talking about are objective - where she's from, what material the costume is made of, how expensive the material was, who the band is working with, etc. - Se and Te. Very little about her subjective state and reactions. Also, when the interviewer acts her if she is excited about the show her response is "Yes, I'm excited."

I'm looking at her movements, facial expressions, and how she expends energy. She is not EP or EJ temperament, and I doubt she is IJ.

Her being artistic can be evidence. But I was focusing more on how she was touching the fabric. It as if she feels the fabic while touching it, instead of just touching it. I find this trait common in SEI. It is a sensing thing. Other types like EIE and IEI would not touch fabric in this manner.

You have the right to disagree.

[Exodus]

I'm looking at her movements, facial expressions, and how she expends energy. She is not EP or EJ temperament, and I doubt she is IJ.

I agree she seems more IP in this video, but in the Letterman interview she's way more active and talkative, bringing in all sorts of information not directly related to his questions.

Her being artistic can be evidence. But I was focusing more on how she was touching the fabric. It as if she feels the fabic while touching it, instead of just touching it. I find this trait common in SEI. It is a sensing thing. Other types like EIE and IEI would not touch fabric in this manner.

She is using Si, but she's not verbalizing it at all. How the fabric feels is exactly one of the things I would expect an SEI to talk about.

[machintruc]

I'm looking at her movements, facial expressions, and how she expends energy. She is not EP or EJ temperament, and I doubt she is IJ.

She's an extroverted IJ. Introtims can be extroverts, remember

[dbmmama]

She did not write that song.

Also if you look at interviews she is way too calm and relaxed to be EP temperament.

As far her being impulsive; she was not always on drugs like that. Or whatever mental issues she going through.

Spears is SEI. As is Stefani. You have to look past the image that has been created around them.

Old interview of Stefani before she got famous.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VRUaN...eature=related

I think she is quite SEI here.

i can see sei here and then realizing she has grown and developed into her 30s, she just might be sei. i can see it.

[dbmmama]

she's Ni-ENFj 3w4 - too raw to be Fe subtype. what britney is is irrelevant.

i want to see what you're seeing and why.

can you elaborate a bit for me?

this one is important to me because she is "my girl"... my sis thinks i'm beta and i want to understand the difference between beta "edge" and alpha "edge."

[strrrng]

you just gotta look at her...Ni-ENFj's are the most visceral type imo...the Ni/Se pairing is strong as hell, they love to get inside ppls heads (not as much as Ni-INFps though lol). anyway, she has a sense of control, which points to EJ, but she's, like I said, too raw not to be Ni subtype. As for the enneagram, eh, she's kinda looking outward for praise...not detached enough to be a 7 imo

[strrrng]

this one is important to me because she is "my girl"... my sis thinks i'm beta and i want to understand the difference between beta "edge" and alpha "edge."

alphas don't have an "edge" lolz


the only alpha I can think of that does is allie, and that's cause she's sx instinct

[dbmmama]

alphas don't have an "edge" lolz


the only alpha I can think of that does is allie, and that's cause she's sx instinct

ok, then. i've got "edge" i've just "toned it down" over the years....and don't always come from the fire in my belly the way i did when i was younger. to react that way was first nature, easy. i've learned and practiced "control" over the fire. it's a continual process but i'm finding it's worth it in the longterm of my own personal happiness as well as my relationships with others. i've learned to love and embrace a bit of rain...water...and experience it's calming effect (which is not natural, but appreciated sometimes or i know i would explode with the fire getting "out of hand") that has not been a "pretty" sight, especially because i saw it within my own mother and knew i had to control it better with my own children or i would do what she did to me...

[dbmmama]

you just gotta look at her...Ni-ENFj's are the most visceral type imo...the Ni/Se pairing is strong as hell, they love to get inside ppls heads (not as much as Ni-INFps though lol). anyway, she has a sense of control, which points to EJ, but she's, like I said, too raw not to be Ni subtype. As for the enneagram, eh, she's kinda looking outward for praise...not detached enough to be a 7 imo

i had to look up visceral...abdomen, intestine. yes, my "place" of "weakness" and strength. 3rd chakra, fire....

when my fire starts burning....and getting out of hand, it manifests in those areas of my body as well.

thanks dear.

[Elro]

Se-dom? I always figured SLE, but I guess SEE is possible also.

[Elro]

By the way, I think Gwen Stephani is annoying as hell. I especially hate her song "Sweet Escape". They play it on the radio all the time, and it makes my ears bleed.

I actually like it. It's catchy. Although if I get overexposed to it (which is possible because it's an option in my workplace's jukebox - Nickelback's "Rock Star" plays almost every night, for example) I might feel the same way.

[Exodus]

you just gotta look at her...Ni-ENFj's are the most visceral type imo...

Most visceral? Bullshit. The visceral-ness you are seeing is strong Se (and Fe, maybe).

Not really. Just because FDG is a ENTj doesn't mean he will automatically dislike SEIs on cue.

By the way, I think Gwen Stephani is annoying as hell. I especially hate her song "Sweet Escape". They play it on the radio all the time, and it makes my ears bleed. I also dislike Britney Spears. So, in these cases, dislike of a certain person is not a very accurate indicator of their type.

+1

I happen to really like that song, but it has little to do with her type.